15243. Middletown Savings Bank (Middletown, NY)

Bank Information

Episode Type
Run Only
Bank Type
savings bank
Start Date
November 28, 1884
Location
Middletown, New York (41.445, -74.424)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini
Short Digest
82382947

Response Measures

Accommodated withdrawals

Description

The articles describe the failure/suspension and receivership of the Middletown National Bank (not the savings bank). That failure precipitated a brief run on the Middletown Savings Bank, which paid out about $20,000โ€“$26,000, published a statement it could meet demands and waived thirty days' notice, and the run ended. The savings bank did not suspend or close.

Events (1)

1. November 28, 1884 Run
Cause
Local Banks
Cause Details
News of the failure/suspension of the Middletown National Bank (irregular loans by its president) triggered depositor withdrawals from the savings bank.
Measures
Published statement that they were ready to pay all depositors, waiving the thirty days notice; paid out about $20,000โ€“$26,000 and the run ended.
Newspaper Excerpt
A slight run occurred at the Middletown Savings Bank to-day. $20,000 was drawn.
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (4)

Article from New-York Tribune, November 29, 1884

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

A NATIONAL BANK FAILS. THE DISASTER DUE TO IRREGULAR LOANS. THE UNITED STATES BANK EXAMINER TAKES CHARGE OF THE BANK IN MIDDLETOWN. IBY TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNG) MIDDLETOWN, Nov. 28.-The Middletown Na. tional Bank suspended to-day. The bank examiner, George I. May, arrived from Washington at noon to-day and took possession of the bank until an examination of its affairs can be made. It is impossible now to tell the amount of the deficit. The president, Thomas King, takes the entire responsibility for the failure, fully exonerating the directors and officers. King had been accepting drafts irregularly from Benjamin D. Brown, a grain operator who formerly did business here and latterly was interested in large elevators in Indianapolis and in Burlington, Iowa. King kept an account of these transactions, which caused the failure of the bank, in a memorandum. of which the cashier and directors had no knowledge until a week ago. The directors tried to tide over the trouble, but the amount of the indebtedness was found to be too large. On Wednesday afternoon they decided that they must suspend, and telegraphed to the Controller of the Currency. It is believed that the deficit will use up the entire capital of $200,000 and surplus of $115,000, with possibly an assessment upon the shareholders, too. Several months ago the directors found that King had lent about $70,000 to Brown, and directed that the debt should be reduced. The Department in Washington also found fault with the excessive oan. King was instructed to lend no more of the bank's money to Brown. In spite of these instructions, King continued to advance money, not in the shape of loans, but by accepting drafts without adequate surety in large numbers, carefully concealing the transactions from the directors and cashier. Many believe that King and Brown were partners in grain speculations, as otherwise they cannot account for the influence which Brown had over him. King is completely prostrated and is unable to give a satisfactory explanation of the matter. Brown and King have both made assignments to the bank. Houston and Conklin, grain dealers who endorsed Brown's paper made an assignment to-day as did c. c. V. Ketcham, Krain doaler, for the same reason. A slight run occurred at the Middletown Savings Bank to-day. $20,000 was drawn. This bank is sound and able to meet all demands. The Treasurer of the village kept his accounts with the suspended bank, where were deposited also the funds of the Board of Education. These funds will be locked up for the present. The directors of the bank have unanimously recommended to the Conptroller of the Currency the name of the person whom they desire to be appointed receiver. The failure caused great astou. ishment and considerable excitement, as the bank is widely known, and was considered one of the soundest in this part of the State. Brown is severely denounced and King 18 greatly blamed. Some embarrassment will follow the suspension, but it is hoped that no more failures will occur. King was the last person who would have been onepeeted of such irregular transactions. as he has been considered remarkably cantious and conservative. The Board of Directors of the bank have unanimously petitioned the Conptroller of the Currency to appoint Moses D. Stivers receiver. Mr. Stivers is the senior editor of The Press and for fourteen years was collector of internal revenue in the Xith District, New-York. Brown's method was to draw time-drafts on different parties with whom he was doing business at various points in the East. Accompanying them were bitts of lading. These were sent to the Middletown Bank, with instructions that the bills should not be delivered until the drafts were paid. King was in the habit of allowing Brown to take bills of lading to collect. The latter did not turn over the money collected. and when the drafts were due the bank had to provide for them. When King made his confession to the directors, Brown was summoned and promised to make the bank secure. but failed. Brown's indebteducss is not positively known. It is thought to be over $50,000. The directors say that all depositors and creditors, except stockholders, will be paid in full.


Article from The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, November 29, 1884

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

ANOTHER BANK Given Up the Sponge-The President Assumes All Blame. MIDDLETOWN, N. Y., Nov. 28.-The Middletown National bank has failed. The doors were closed this morning. The failure was caused by the President, Thomas King, who accepted large drafts from Benjamin D. Brown, a grain dealer of Indianapolis and Burlington, Iowa, without security. Brown has made an assignment. The capital of the bank is $100,000 and the surplus $115,000. The extent of loss is not known vet definitely. The depositors will lose nothing. President King takes all the blane on himself. His recent advances were made without the knowledge of the other officers and directors. The Bank Examiner is now on his way from Washington. There is a slight run on the Savings bank here, but the latter is in no way involved, and will stand the run easily. There had been rumors in circulation for several days past that the bank was in financial straits, and some reports had it that the bank would surely suspend to. day, It was said that the cashier telegraphed on Wednesday for a bank ex amlner, and that the directors were in secret session all day yesterday discussing affairs. President King, of the institution is very sick and cannot be seen. The National Bank of New York is its correspondent in that city. The news of the Middletown bank failure caused great excitement in the eastern part of Orange county. The Newburg banks are not much affected by the failure. The Middletown institution owed one of them $3,000, which probably will be paid. Among the indirectors of the auspended bank is U. S. Senator Charles H. Van Wyck, of Nebraska, formerly of this county.


Article from Savannah Morning News, November 30, 1884

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

MIDDLETOWN'S BROKEN BANK. The A appointment of a Receiver Declared Unavoidable. MIDDLETOWN, Y., Nov. 29.-The run on the savings bank yesterday drew out about $20,000. It still continued to-day, but was much smaller, and will doubtless end with to-day. The bank is abundantly able to pay all demands, and published in the local papers yesterday a statement that they were ready to pay all depositors, waiving the thirty days notice. No fears are entertained about its safety by the mass of and the broken of depositors. national bank, President is in King, bed, cannot be seen. There are no new developments in the matter. A RECEIVER A NECESSITY. WASHINGTON, Nov. 29.-The Comptroller of the Currency has received a telegram from Bank Examiner May, in charge of the Middletown National Bank, at Middletown, New York, saying that it will be necessary to place the bank in the hands of a receiver. AN ASSIGNMENT SET ASIDE. JACKSON, MISS., Nov. 29.-In the Federal Court to-day the suit of the Hanover National Bank, of New York, against the Mississippi Valley Bank, which has occupied the attention of the court for several days, was concluded and the assignment was set aside in favor of the attaching creditors. The case will be carried to the Supreme Court of the United States. NEW YORK BREWERS GO UNDER. NEW YORK, Nov. 29.-Wm. H. Burr, Henry S. Burr and Emil Schwab, composing the firm of Burr, Son & Co., brewers, at 227 West Eighteenth street, filed an assignment to-day for the benefit of their creditors to Oliver S. Ackley, giving preferences amounting to $108,887. DALLAS' INSOLVENT BANKERS. DALLAS, TEX., Nov. 29.-In the United States Court to-day an attachment suit on the bank building and other city property belonging to Adams & Leonard, the bankers who recently assigned, and proceedings in garnishment on the Dallas Real Estate Building Association, Esquella Cattle Company, and W. H. Flippen, the assignee of the bank, were entered by the Missouri Pacific Railroad Company, who set forth that the company made deposits with Adams & Leonard amounting to $80,500, which they sue to recover. Other smaller attachments have also been instituted against the bank's property. The court records show that Adams & Leonard, about an hour before filing their assignment, filed a deed of trust on the bank building to N. W. Godbold as trustee in consideration of a promissory note of $10,000 held by H. R. Hoarne, of Hoarne, Texas. The assets of the suspended firm, as shown by the schedule filed, are $614,600, being nearly double their liabilities.


Article from The Indianapolis Journal, December 1, 1884

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

[From the Journal of Sunday.] THE MIDDLETOWN BANK. After Assigning, Brown Obtains Drafts on Another Bank-The Run Ended. MIDDLETOWN, N. Y., Nov. 29.-The run on the savings bank ended this evening, after $26,000 had been paid out. President King, of the broken national bank, is in bed and can not be seen. There are no new developments in the matter. On Thursday last, after B. D. Brown left thi village, where he had made a general assignment to the Middletown National Bank, he went to Goshen. He there poreured from the Goshen National Bank drafts on New York, aggregating $13,000, which he took to New York next morning and doubtless had cashed. Rumor says he obtained the drafts without sufficient security, or none at all.