City National Bank (Denver, CO)

Episode Information

Episode UID
195501123
Episode Type
Run Only
Bank Type
national
Bank ID
19550 national
Charter Number
1955
Start Date
July 18, 1893
Location
Denver, Colorado (39.739, -104.985)

Metadata

Model
gemini-3-flash-preview (chosen from majority vote of a three-model LLM ensemble)
Short Digest
b7ff5959de5e5fe8

Response Measures

Accommodated withdrawals

Description

The bank experienced a heavy run during the July 1893 Denver panic but remained open and resumed normal operations by July 20.

Events (4)

1. April 9, 1872 Chartered
Source
historical_nic
2. July 18, 1893 Run
Cause
Local Banks
Cause Details
The failure of the Union National Bank and other local institutions triggered a general panic and runs on all clearing house banks.
Measures
The bank remained open and continued paying out until the run exhausted itself.
Newspaper Excerpt
A run is now being made on City National, German National, First National, Colorado National and all the eleven clearing house banks.
Source
newspapers
3. July 20, 1893 Other
Newspaper Excerpt
This morning when the First, Colorado, Denver, City and American Nationals opened their doors, there was hardly a dozen depositors in all of them at the paying tellers' windows. ... the run was over by noon.
Source
newspapers
4. January 7, 1895 Voluntary Liquidation
Source
historical_nic

Newspaper Articles (18)

Article from The Jersey City News, July 18, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

EXTRA! DENVER'S BANK PANIC Three More Collapse and Rumors Are Rife on Several. DENVER, Col., July 18.-The Union National Bank, of which R. W. Wood, bury is president, failed to open its doors this morning. The capital is $1,000,000. No statement can be bad. A run is now being made on City National. German National, First National, Colorado National and all the eleven clearing house banks. The panic is on. DENVER, Col., July 18, 1893.-The National Bank of Commerce has closed its doors. Ex.Governor Job A. Cooper is President of this bank. DENVER, Col,, July 18, 1893. I The Commercial National Bank has closed its doors. A notice says:-"This bank has gone into liquidation by order of the Board of Directors,"


Article from Asheville Daily Citizen, July 18, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

CLOSED DOORS. Serious Times Among The Denver Banks. DENVER, Col., July 18.-The Union National bank, of which W. R. Woodbury is president, failed to open its doors this morning. Capital $100,000. No statement can be had. A run is now being made on the City National, German National, the First National, the Colorado National and all the eleven clearing house banks. The Commercial National bank and the National Bank of Commerce have closed their doors. FORT SCOTT, Kans, July 18.-The First National bank of this city, the oldest financial institution in south eastern Kansas, has suspended payment. TOLEDO, O., July 18.-The Citizens' bank of Ada, the most prominent one in Hardin county, failed to open its doors this morning. Its owner, Peter F. Ahlfield, has controlled it over a quarter of a century and is one of the wealthiest men in that section.


Article from Deseret Evening News, July 18, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

The failure of two banks at Denver today was raised by rumor in this city to the collapse of eleven, or all the clearing house banks. The latter report doubtless arone from the fact that a run was being made on all of the banks, but with the exceptions noted they stood the pressure.


Article from Waterbury Evening Democrat, July 19, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

A FINANCIAL FLUTTER Denver Still Somewhat Uneasy After the Panic. THREE BANKS EXPECT TO RESUME. They lar All For Promise to Pay Depositors to Collect Dollar. but It will Dol. Went Down. sas Banks the Dollars A String Take of Time Kan. tion DENVER. here this July 19 The financial have easy and feverish. morning was decidedly situa unbeen three expected after Nothing else the Union the National, when national Commercial yesterday panic, could National National owing to the -closed small The heavy excited depositors their doors in the private Bank institution of Commerce Mercantile demands of bank. and suspended. Mining Exchange doing business bank, owing to the close building. also made through which its of the Union before had savings banks on the day The suspension of three clearances were of that at the hour for the all had gathered opening the banks nearly munity crowds the so alarmed com the the tional, run German was the heavy. and financial City although National institutions the in banks First front At felt Na. the The It the situation. streets was unusual People's were full of people to or some two discussing extent others and run talk. there was The an much orderly crowd. however and their soon exhausted itself on and the affairs People's conservative bank excite other normal the run banks WAS condition. over by At 1 the resumed City National ment except the o'clock, and the noon. the teller crowd kept in Ger- in man front National was of all over the by window noon German, all At the the the line at lowing of the Union on the front and doors There notice was posted National after side is in bank the hands National president: The Union signed by R. w bank Woodbury, the fol. of the in $1.000,000.00 two past sets meet which liabilities our local the the of week If paid again. sents fully may no by can Doors. Bank No the than posted to at and door each began crowds for indihours though the were viduals changing the crowds the statement of variety putting a varies it. Nobody frightened and the the that deposits The did bank immercial its open doors the he inevitable d This bank has of of the board Those There was to who stopped ly the about of an in fident of the along the ing teller gold doors the he he passed out were presented of time Bythat had positors the the officers decided and cash forelock on in hand still of at the each bank "This inside board Those of directors. is of few trace the was in to many paused ny The Mercant 88 ated. with in the en located its doors closed er city Assignee n the the itor, bank president r of the directors er being among men is business pension The suspens at the by Union about the bank through nt made clearance he that the bank due dollar had ery This bank to in only operation ms comparatively at little ld The First arat a little National on on sold. lis the Think its. York fatt at the for closing It bullion It was after hour money he had bank due President H. D. Moffatt be National greatly exceeded old always withdrawal house during stated the that day the deposits of the First res and most is most in owned don exclusivesyovatively the general opinion and men business age that and and mild may way en af close continulthough against no more the panic obliged banker day or two. and is It of hay and fidence in the in the that the as hat a withdrawn will better result believed feeling will strong by financiers that banks more to of resum circles_ The which will be "Posited in he business The in short easier financial constant rbtus that ne scared the crisis depositors is what the banks been the three during the less banks than $0,000,000 L by bankers brought about Of has this be $3,000,000 regular the alt. that and the res posit suppose 000,000 contain vaults hoarded lines are of the in full, homes city, there of but The to there is &5. is the safety de months amount ve- WAS are hidden. let into If circulation places one-fifth in which of that workingment their savings


Article from Pawtucket Tribune, July 19, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Financial Panic at Denver. DENVER, July 19.-The Union National bank failed to open its doors yesterday. The capital is $1,000,000. A run is now being made on the City National, German National, First National and Colonial and even the clearing house banks. There is a panic in financial circles. The National Bank of Commerce and the Commercial National bank have closed their doors.


Article from San Antonio Daily Light, July 20, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

STILL SHAKEY At Denver, Although the Report Says it Looks Better. DENVER, Col., July 20.-There will apparently be no more bank failures in Denver. The panic wore itself out yesterday with the failure of the People's, German and State National banks. This morning when the Colorado, Denver City and American National banks opened their doors, there was hardly a dozen depositors in all of them at the paying tellers' windows. At the First and Colorado National banks a long string of depositors reaching nearly to the street were lined up in front of the receiving teller's window, and money was going back into the bank's vaults, almost as rapidly as it was withdrawn during the past three days. The German, State and People's National banks could pay three for one, if they could only realize on securities. There may be a few commercial failures in the city within the next few days as a result of the suspension of banks, but it is believed, that in no instance, whether banking or commercial house, will failure be complete and `resumption of business will surely follow shortly. It is stated today that the McNamara Dry Goods House, which failed Monday for $260,000, have settled with their principal creditors, and will resume business Monday.


Article from The Western Sentinel, July 20, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

A Panic. DENVER, Col., July 18.-A regular panic has been experienced in this city today. The first failure announced was that of the First National Bank, with a capital of $1,000,000, which precipitated a run on the City National, the German National and all the clearing houses. The National Bank of Commerce closed,


Article from The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, July 21, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

THE PANIC OVER. Denver Banking Houses will All Resume. Matters Settle Down. DENVER, July 20.-There will apparently be no more bank failures in Denver. The panic run itself out yesterday with the failure of the People's, German and State national banks. This morning when the First Colorado, Denver, City and American nationals opened their doors there was hardly a dozen depositors in all of them at the paying teller's window. In the First and Colorado nationals a long string of depositors reaching nearly to the street were lined up in front of the tellers' windows and the money was going back into the bank vaults almost as rapidly as it was withdrawn during the past three days. The German, State and People's Nationals could pay $3 for $1 if they could realizo on securities. There may be n few commercial failures in the city within the next few days as a result of the suspension of banks, but it is bolieved that in no instance, whether a banking or commercial house, will the be follow tion failure of business complete will and surely that resumpshortly. It is stated to-day that the McNainara dry goods house which failed Monday for $200,000 have settled with their principal creditors and will resume business Monday.


Article from The Sun, July 21, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

HELP FOR DENVER BANKS. COMPTROLLER ECKELS WILL GIVE THEM ALL THE AID HE CAN. Ec will Grant Them Time to Collect oney to Start Again-The News Halled with Joy in Denver Many People Putting Their Money Back in the Banks Sun Open-A Sharp Brenk in General Electric the Feature Yesterday in Wall StreetThe Army of Unemployed is Very Large. WASHINGTON, Jul" 20.-Comptroller Eckels. immediately on his return from New York this morning. addressed to Frank Adams. the Nntional Bank Examiner at Denver. a despatch defining the policy of the Administration with reference to insolvent national banking institutions generally. as follows: "I wish you would announce to the officers the banks which have failed in Denver that my intention to lend them every aid possible looking toward speedy resumption on their part. and that I shall grant to them sufflcient time to enable them to not only collect in such amounts as are speedily collectible. but to get together such amounts of money as will enable them to open upon a small basis. It seems to me that such citizens as have by a foolish course of conduct in withdrawing deposits from banks which so long enjoyed their complete confldence. and brought about this condition. ought. in view of the damage they have done their city. as quickly as possible to repair it by standing ready to deposit with them. I fully appreciate all the circumstances of the situation. and. that no unnecessary loss may be entailed. you are authorized to employ as assistants. to protect paper and collect in moneys. the most competent and trustworthy employees in such institutions. I have also ordered Examiner McHugh of Iowa to report at once to assist you. I desire that this telegram be given to the press at Denver. evidencing as t does that the Comptroller has faith in the ability of the banks of Denver to resume. and of his desire to lend them every assistance consistentwith his official duty. When asked to express more fully his views the condition of affairs. Mr. Eckels said the failures on in Denver yesterday. like a number of other national bank failures. were caused by no fault of the bank officials. but through a foolish and uncalled-for lack of confidence on the part of depositors. It in my intention." he said. where a bank has been properly conducted. and whose assets under ordinary circumstances would have permitted it to remain solvent. to give the institution every opportunity to resume business. Allthe Denver banks that failed were well conducted. and every opportunity will be given them to reopen. The people who have caused the Denver disaster by foolish runs should do all they can to help the banks resume. Notifications of two more failures reached Mr. Eckels this forenoon. The unfortunate banks are the First National Bank of Harriconville. Mo which went under this morning. and the Oklahoma National Bank of Oklahoma City. Oklahoma. which closed its doors yesterday Comptroller Eckels's efforts to secure a reopening of the insolvent Chemical Bank of Chicago have failed. This morning Mr. Eckels received the following telegram from the Chemical Bank Committee: After long. patient. and earnest efforts. the committee of the stockholders of the Chemical National Bank of Chicago has concluded that resumption is not practicable at this time. At first the problem seemed easy. but the many financial disasters throughout the country have excited the public and produced unusual cath tion. and made it very difficult to collect outstanding bills or raise money by usual processes. The conditions Imposed by the Comptrol or were well received. but the present stringency seems an obstacle too serious to be overcome by the stockholders. DENVER. July 20.-There will apparently be no more bank failures in Denver. The panic wore itself out yesterday with the failure of the People's. German, and State National banks. This morning. when the First, Colorado. Denver. City. and American Nationals opened their doors. there was hardly a dozen depositors in all of them at the paving tellers' windows. In the First and Colorado Nationals along string of depositors reaching nearly the street were lined up in front of the reselving tellers windows. and the money was going back into the bank vaults almost as rapidly as it was withdrawn during the past three days. The German. State. and People's (nationals) could pay $3 for $1 if they could realize on securities. There may be a few commercial failures in the city within the next few days. result of the suspension of banks. but it 16 believed that in no instance. whether a banking or commercial house, will the failure becomplete. and that resumption of business will surely follow shortly. It is said to-day that the McNamara dry goods house. which failed on Monday for $250,000. has settled with its principal creditors. and will resume business on Monday The cheering news from Washington has had a wonderful effect upon Denver. The despatch from Comptroller of the Currency Eckels to the effect that he would give every possible aid to the banks of this city is applauded on overy side Bank Examiner Adams. to whom the telegram was addressed. is besieged by excited people anxious to hear a confirmation of the good report and get an expression from him. Mr. Eckeis's comments on the foolish course of those Denver citizens who had lost contidence in the banks are strongly commended. The newspapers ran off extras announcing the news. and already things begin to wear a brighter aspect. The officers of the several closed banks all notify the public that they will be able to pay every cent due to customers. But in some cases it will take some time to realize on securities. It is learned that heavy withdrawals have been made from several of the banks during the past few months. which would indicate that some of the far seeing ones anticipated trouble such as has come upon the city in the past few days. It is noticeable that very few of the merchants or business men of the city withdrew their deposits. the run being made principally by the working people and poorer classes of customers. The newspapers feel greatly the distress. every daily excepting one having curtailed expenses by reducing in size or using largertype. The closing down of many silver mines, smelters. and the reduction of the working forces of coal mines. railways. and manufactories in this State has, however. caused a deplorab condition of affairs among the laboring classes. It WAS estimated that to-day there 10.000 men in Denver unable to secure


Article from The Sun, July 21, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

liabilities are believed to be covered by the assets. CHICAGO. July 20.-It was said in court today that the assets of the suicide banker. Herman Schaffner. would not pay over 12Β½ per cent. of the liabilities. Judge Tuley this morning appointed N. H. Culver receiver for the Commercial Lumber Company of Havenswood. The concern was incorporated in 1891 with a capital of $30,000. It is declared that the assets are in excess of the liabilities. SAN FRANCISCO. July 20.-Attachments have been filed against the Union Stock Yards Company. whose meat packing establishment is at Rodeo. These claims are said to be preliminary to larger suits by Eastern holders of the company's bonds. The plant has practically shut down. It cost $1,000,000 and Was started on May 15. Attorney-General Hart has decided that the People's Home Savings Bank. which closed a few weeks ago. is solvent, and recommends that if the bank can make sufficient collections within a reasonable time it should do so. SAN BERNARDINO. Cal., July 20.-The national band examiners who have been! looking into the affairs of the First National Bank of this city have made a report to Comptroller Eckels. recommending that the bank be allowed to open at once. They say they find the affairs of the bank in good condition. ASHLAND. Wis., July 20.-The Northern Manufacturing Company. manufacturers of hard wood. assigned yesterday. Assets. $60.000: liabilities unknown. The failure is due to the recent loss of the factory by fire. TACOMA. Wash.. July 20.-S. B. Dusinberre. cashier of the Bank of Puyallup. who was arrested forthe emberglement of $41,000 and released on bail, has been rearrested on a second charge of embezzlement. Ho was held in $15,000 bail. in default of which he went to jail. DENVER, July 20.-The First National banks at CaΓ±on City and Grand Junction. this State. failed to open their doors this morning. The failures were caused by the suspension of the Denver banks. TOPEKA. Kan., July 20.-Notice of the failure of the Bank of Belleville. Republic county. has been received at the State Bank Commissioner's office. It was a private bank with a capital of $20,000.


Article from Arizona Silver Belt, July 22, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

The work of closing Denver banks by excited depositors may be said to have been effectually completed. The night of the 18th, the city was agog, and but few retired to rest. Streets in the vicinity of banks were crowded with people many of whom stood in line in order to maintain a position which would favor them in reaching paying tellers' counters at the earliest possible moment, but the night's vigils did not avail them. Before the hour for opening notices were posted on doors of banks that on account of exhaustion of ready cash, consequent upon the previous day's run, the bank would not open and thus it stood, at latest dates. This is not the worst feature of the depressing influence that encompasses Colorado. Mines in every part of the state are shut down. Leadville is as pulseless as a graveyard, and some of her best paying mines are virtually abandoned by the withdrawal of the pumps and consequent ruin by reason of accumulation of water, which in a brief period fills every shaft, tunnel and drift.


Article from The Dickinson Press, July 22, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANKS IN DENVER FAIL. Denver, July -The Union National bank, of which R. W Woodbury is president. failed to open its doors yesterday morning The capital is $5,000,000. No statement can be had. A run was made on the City National, German National, First National, Colorado National and all the eleven clearing house banks. The Commercial National bank and the Na tional Bank of Commerce are also closed. Ex-Gov. Job Cooper is president of the last named bank.


Article from The Helena Independent, July 22, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

COMPTROLLER ECKLES showed the right spirit when he announced to the officers of the Denver banks that he would lend every possible assistance in order that they might resume business at an early date. He fully appreciated the fact that these banks were closed not because of the lack of sufficient capital or bad management, but simply because of a run of depositors who could neither be advised nor restrained. Under these conditions the comptroller is entitled to all credit for his efforts as an officer of the government to bring business back into its legitimate channels.


Article from The Progressive Farmer, July 25, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

RUN ON DENVER BANKS. One Closes Its Doors and There is a Run on the Others. DENVER, Col, July 18.-The Union National bank, of which R. W. Woodbury is President, failed to open its doors this morning Capital, $170,000. No statement can be had. A run is now being made on the City National, German National, First National, Colorado National and the eleven clearing house banks. The panic is on.


Article from Southwest-Sentinel, July 25, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

LAST week was a bad one for the banks of Denver. Depositors had been drawing their deposits for weeks and a number of the banks were in bad condition. The failure of three savings banks precipitated a run on all the banks in the city and there were several big failures.


Article from River Falls Journal, July 27, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

WILL AID THE BANKS. Comptroller Eckels Will Do All in His Power to Help Embarrassed But Reputable Banks to Resume-The Flurry in Denver About Over. WASHINGTON, July 21.-Comptroller Eckles has sent a dispatch to Bank Examiner Adams at Denver in which he said, in effect, that he would give every possible aid to the banks of that city, and would grant to them sufficient time to enable them to not only collect such amounts as are speedily collectable, but to get together such amounts of money as will enable them to open upon a small basis. The comptroller also said: "It seems to me that such citizens as have. by a foolish course of conduct in withdrawing deposits from banks which so long enjoyed their complete confidence, brought about this condition, ought, in view of the damage they have done their city, as quickly as possible to repair it by standing ready to deposit with them.' Referring to his action the comptroller said the failures in Denver, like a number of other national bank failures, were caused by no fault of the bank officials, but through a foolish and uncalled-for lack of confidence on the part of depositors. He continued: "It is my Intention where a bank has been properly conducted and whose assets under or dinary circumstances would have permitted it to remain solvent, to give the institution every opportunity to resume business. All the Denver banks that failed were well conducted, and every opportunity will be given them to reopen. The people who have caused the Denver disaster by foolish runs should do all they can to help the banks resume." "What is true regarding Denver applies with equal force to banks in other portions of the west where suspension has not resulted from reckless investments or bad managemento the part of officers. Wherever the citizens of a place have precipitated trouble by*instituting a run upon long-established and well-conducted institutions it is but just that they should take hold and assist these banks by redepositing with them, thus placing them in A position to resume their business on a sound financial basis. Wherever possible and advisable the most trusted employes of suspended banking institutions are to be retained by the bank examiners in the interests of the creditors and stockholders, so that every possible means of realizing on the absets of the institution may be accomplished. Instructions to the examiners. however, are to the effect that only in cases of reputable, -established banks are these conditions to be imposed, and no wild-cat institutions or methods will be sanctioned by this office." DENVER, Col., July 21.-There will be no more bank failures in Denver. The panie wore itself out Wednesday with the failure of the People's, German and State national banks. This morning when the First, the Colorado, Denver, City and American nationals opened their doors there was hardly a dozen depositors in all of them at the paying teller's window. In the First and the Colorado nationals a long string of depositors reaching nearly to the street were lined up in front of the receiving teller's windows, and the money was going back into the bank vaults almost as rapidly as it was withdrawn during the past three days. The German, State and People's nationals could pay $3 for $1 if they could realize on securities. Bank Examiner Adams has received a dispatch from Comptroller Eckels which has gone far toward restoring confidence. The officers of the several closed banks all notify the public that they will be able to pay every cent due to customers. But in some cases it will take time to realize on securities. It is learned that heavy withdrawals have been made from several of the banks during the last few months, which would indicate that some of the farseeing anticipated the trouble. It is noticeable that very few of the merchants or business men of the city withdrew their deposits, the runs being made principally by the working pec ple and poorer classes of customers. There may be a few commercial failures in the city within the next few days as a result of the suspension of banks, but it is believed that in no instance, whether a banking or commercial house, will the failure be complete. A resumption of business will surely follow shortly. It is stated that the McNamara dry goods house, which failed Monday for $260,000, have settled with their principal creditors and will resume business Monday. The Flanders dry goods house, occupying premises of five store fronts and five stories high on Sixteenth street, was attached by H. F. Bradley, of Boulder, Col., for $24,000. There is no definite statement of the condition of the firm yet available. Competent judges place the assets at $200,000 with liabilities at $125,000. The failure was caused by the suspension of the People's national bank, to which $25,000 was due. The Union bank of Greeley has closed, with liabilities of $100,000 and assets of $300,000. The Greeley national bank also suspended, but has made no statement. The failures are attributed to the Denver troubles. The Bank of Loveland, at Loveland, Col., has closed its doors, having been caught by the general depression. President Benson, of the bank, assures depositors they will be paid in full. Word has reached here that the First national banks at Canon City and Grand Junction, in this state, failed to open their doors. There are as yet no particulars, but probably the failures were caused by the suspension of Denver banks. The banking house of J. B. Wheeler City and Manitou


Article from Martinsburg Herald, July 29, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

# The Cloud in the East. "The threatened closing of the mills in the East I regard as a much more serious feaure of the present situation than the closing of the Denver banks," says a New York banker. So it is beyond question. The Denver banks were forced to close by the run resulting from the insane ravings of the Governor of Colorado and his hoodlum convention. The trouble with the mills in the East is of a different nature. They are confronted by the free trade policy of the party in power. The market will not take their product and they cannot afford to tie up money in goods that may be depreciated by an act of Congress before they can be marketed. Some of them can suspend operations and live. Others must run or go under, and since they cannot sell they must do the other thing. If there was no fear of a radical change in the tariff policy there mills would go on as before. It is easy to fix the blame without going far. Wheeling Intelligencer.


Article from San Antonio Daily Light, July 31, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

IT is not the Wall street gold bugs who are responsible for the financial troubles in Denver, but the distrust and lack of confidence of her own people. There is no bank that can stand a drainage of hundreds of thousands in a day without preparing for it. There is not a doubt that the Denver banks are sound, but this insane run upon them for hundreds of thousands of dollars has simply forced them to suspend payments. It is a fool movement of the home simpletons.