Click image to open full size in new tab
Article Text
# GRAND JURY REPORT
Eureka, Nevada, April 24, 1912.
To the Hon. Peter Breen, Judge of the Third Jadicial District of the State of Nevada, in and for the County of Eureka.
We, the Grand Jury impanneled by your Honor and assigned to duty on the 17th day of April, A. D. 1912, having investigated all cases submitted and all public matters brought to our notice by the District Attorney and others, do now submit our report.
The different committees were appointed as follows:
Committee on Books-W. J. Mahoney, T. A. Bruffey, John Swan.
Committee on Public Buildings-O. O. H. Hjul, D. Morris, F. Kopp.
Committee on Fire and Water-Spencer Plummer, E. Affranchino, A. C. Dibble.
Committee on Morals-John Depaoli, E. T. Flavin, J. J. Siri.
Committee on Roads and Bridges-T. A. Burdick, Dennis Keefe, John Conway.
In the case of the State of Nevada vs. Jean Banon, charged with arson, the bill was ignored.
The Grand Jury, as a body, investigated certain statements concerning the Board of County Commissioners as published in the Eureka SENTINEL on the 16th day of March, 1912, and the causes that led up to that and similar publications. After a full and impartial hearing, it is concluded that said statements, or, charges, so-called, consisted of an ill-advised attack upon the Board of County Commissioners, which was inspired by a misunderstanding of the respective rights and duties of the County Board of Education in the matter of obtaining funds by taxation, and, backed up, undoubtedly, by persons who are interested in provoking trouble. If the publisher of the Eureka SENTINEL had refused the communication, as he knew that he should, the matter would have been unimportant. It was the publication in the paper which did much of the harm.
The Grand Jury finds that the acts of and the bills, referred to, allowed by the Board of County Commissioners, were legal and proper; and, further finds, that the County Board of Education, in requiring the amount of its estimate from the Board of County Commissioners, were somewhat extravagant. It cannot be denied that after the washout of the railroad about two years ago, the shut-down of the mines and the bankruptcy of the Eureka County Bank, the irritability of some of the residents of this County towards others has been increased through a state of mind resulting from the many losses consequent upon the above named disasters. Much consideration should be and has been shown on this account. But, at the present time, when the railroad is rebuilt, new enterprises are starting and a revival of prosperity seems assured, a condition, involving indiscriminate accusations, must cease; or, must be punished as provided by the laws of this State. The reputation of a man, whether official or personal, is sacred, and must not be made the subject of insulting jest or indiscriminating attack. Those ill-natured persons who offend against this rule, merit and should have the contempt of all good citizens.
The Grand Jury is assured that its investigation of this subject has done good and shall be productive of good results, and that many reprehensible phases shall be eliminated in the future. But, it has not finished its labors in this connection, and, if the matter be deemed of sufficient importance by the Court, the members of the Grand Jury would be willing, and hereby respectfully request to be continued as a body with power to take up again the question of libelling public officials.
County Books
To the Foreman of the Grand Jury-
We. your Committee on County Books