Benton Harbor State Bank (Benton Harbor, MI)

Episode Information

Episode UID
74017871584
Episode Type
Suspension โ†’ Reopening
Bank Type
state
Bank ID
7401787 routing
Routing Number
74-0178
Start Date
December 1, 1931*
Location
Benton Harbor, Michigan (42.117, -86.454)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini (chosen from majority vote of a three-model LLM ensemble)
Short Digest
246ec295b98de2c9

Response Measures

None

Description

Bank closed in December 1931 under a receivership and later reorganized; receiver was discharged prior to reopening.

Events (4)

1. December 1, 1931* Receivership
Newspaper Excerpt
Claims are being filed with the receiver at the Benton Harbor State bank.
Source
newspapers
2. December 1, 1931* Suspension
Cause Details
Bank closed in December 1931 and placed in receivership; specific triggering cause not stated in articles
Newspaper Excerpt
the Benton Harbor State bank closed last December
Source
newspapers
3. April 4, 1932 Other
Newspaper Excerpt
DEPOSITORS SIGNING FOR BANK MERGER โ€” ... headquarters of the reorganization committee of the American National and the Benton Harbor State banks was thronged ... signing the agreement for the opening of the banks as merged institution.
Source
newspapers
4. August 19, 1932 Reopening
Newspaper Excerpt
Reopening of the Benton Harbor State bank was given clear track this morning when Circuit Judge Charles White approved the depositors' agreement and granted their petition to discharge the receiver.
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (19)

Article Text

DEPOSITORS SIGNING FOR BANK MERGER The headquarters of the reorganization committee of the American National and the Benton Harbor State banks was thronged Saturday by depositors who signed the agreement for the opening of the banks as merged institution. The headquarters may be found in the Benton Harbor State bank building, entrance on Michigan street Mr. Hubbard. who is in charge. will be glad explain any portion of the contract which may puzzle any depositor. The program toward the opening of the reorganized bank will depend upon the promptness of the depositors in signing the agreement POLICE RECOVER PURSE purse containing two $5 bills among other things was recovered police for Miss Florine Weber, of Searles avenue, Saturday afternoon after it had been stolen from waiting room in Dr. John Schwarz's office. 14-year-old boy who lives on Territorial road is reported by police to have stolen the purse when he entered the office to canvass shoeshining.


Article Text

URGE DEPOSITORS OF CLOSED SISTER CITY BANKS FILE CLAIMS Depositors in the closed American National and Benton Harbor State banks, which will be reorganized and reopened as one bank, were urged today not to delay in filing their formal claims. Claims are being filed with the receiver at the Benton Harbor State bank. The sooner the claims are filed the faster the work will proceed.


Article Text

DEPOSITORS URGED TO FILE CLAIMS Depositors in the closed American National and Benton Harbor State banks, which will be reorganized and reopened as one bank, were urged today not to delay filing their formal claims Claims are being filed with the receiver at the Benton Harbor State bank. The sooner the claims are filed the faster the work will proceed.


Article Text

WHITE CUTS PAY BANK RECEIVERS A readjustment of the salaries for receivers of state banks in Berrien county today by Judge Charles E. White. On recommendation of the state banking department, the judge signorders which reduce the salaries the various receivers, effective May Judge White stated today that the fixing of salaries for bank receivers on the new scale met with the approval of the state banking department. The reductions were as follows: Berrien County bank, Benton Harbor, from $6,500 to $4,800. Benton Harbor State bank, from $6,000 to $4,800. Bridgman State bank, from $5,000 to $3,600. New Buffalo State bank, from $2,500 to $2,000. Stevensville State bank, from $4,000 to $2,800. Buchanan State bank, from $4,000 to $3,000. LAKE SHORE GREEN HOUSE Now open. Next to Potted plants and evergreens. Rentfrow, Phone 5-7-3t


Article Text

STATE BANK'S DEPOSITORS TO MEET MAY 14 (Continued from Page One) elect, to name the officers of the reorganized bank," Mr. Bookwalter said. "That means that the reorganization will be completely in the hands of those whose money is at present tied up." The depositors' movement to reopen the State bank was launched after the failure of the proposed reorganization and merger of the Benton Harbor State and American National banks by the stockholders of both institutions. The unemployment situation in Italy was aggravated by 69,000 additional jobless in January. Total number of Italian unemployed at present is about 1,151,000.


Article Text

VOTE ON BANK PLAN SATURDAY Arrangements were completed today for Saturday night's meeting of the depositors the Benton Harbor State bank for the purpose of considering of reorganization the The formal plan, as approved by the state banking department, submitted. If the plan proves acceptable and is adopted. committee representing the depositors will be elected for the purpose of promotion and execution. night's meeting is called for o'clock. will be held in the auditorium of the high school on Colfax avenue. The meeting der the auspices of temporary committee representing the depositors, headed by Grant Longenecker, secretary of the People's Savings sociation. This committee proposes resign at tomorrow night's meetwhen elected. the plan of organization is adopted.


Article Text

B. Pledges Pour in More than 50 per cent of the required amount of deposits necessary to reorganize and reopen the closed Benton Harbor State bank been voluntarily signwas today Grant Longenecker, chairman of the depositors' reorganization Total deposits pledged to date for the amount he stated. Efforts are being made to the bank by the middle of July.


Article Text

ANOTHER ADDED TO STATE BANK PLEDGES the Benton Harbor State bank maintaintheir daily average Thursday adding $30,000 to the total pledged for the reorganization reopening agreement. Thursday's pledges amounted $30,226.95, bringing the total posits signed for the reorganization $530,686.17, percent the amount required. The bank will open between the hours and o'clock Saturday evening for the convenience of depositors.


Article Text

MICHIGAN FINANCIAL SITUATION BRIGHTER More Banks Being Reorganized, Less Being Closed Throughout Michigan TWO U. P. BANKS CONSOLIDATE Interest in state banking affairs recently shifted to the Upper Peninsula as the result of a merger in Houghton of two national banks and the suspension of business by two banks at Iron River. The Houghton National Bank and the Citizens Na. tional Bank, of Houghton, were consolidated, the business of both institutions hereafter to be conducted by the Houghton National Bank. All deposit liabilities of the Citizens National have been guaranteed by the remaining institution. Houghton National Bank, headed by A. N. Baudin, was organized in 1865. It has resources in excess of $4,000,000 and deposits of approximately $3,000,000. The Citizens National Bank, organized in 1901, had resources of about $1,000,000 and deposits in excess of $750,000. Its president was A. F. Heidkamp. Merger of the two Houghton national banks, followed several days after the suspension of business by the Miners State Bank, of Iron River, and the Commercial Bank, of Stambaugh. The Iron River bank suspended on June 9. Directors declared the suspension was voted to effect a reorganization. The Commercial Bank, of Stambaugh, a neighbor institution, closed its\ doors the previous day. Two other bank suspensons were reported recently. On June 13 the Sherwood State Bank, Sherwood, organized in 1909, failed to open its doors. The suspension followed recent assessments on the stockholders and other efforts to keep the bank in operation. It is believed that depositors will be paid in full. The private bank of Churchill and Webber, at New Era, failed to open for business on June 14, and will liquidate. The bank was established in 1909 as a branch of the Churchill and Webber bank at Shelby. When the latter institution failed in 1931, the depositors fo the New Era bank agreed not to withdraw their deposts. Resources approximate $113,000. R. E. Reichert, banking commissioner, expresses satisfaction with the progress made in reorganization and reopening activities. He points out that, as a result of the co-operative efforts of depositors and state banking officials, assisted by new legislation, nine banks have been reopened since December 1, 1931. They are at Saline, Ypsilanti, Reading, Romulus, Bessemer, Bridgewater, Petosky, Caledonia and Fenton. Eight more have completed ararngements for reorganization and will reopen shortly. Reichert said that 35 other banks are working toward reorganization and are in various stages of progress, pointing either to their eventual reopening or the establishment of new banks. So far this year, sixteen banks have suspended business, while 13 were closed. Judge Frank L Doty has granted a court order approving the plan for reorganization of the First State Bank, of Milford, following a hearing which showed 89 per cent of the depositors in favor of the plan. A decree was to be signed this week providing for the bank's reopening. The Coloma State Bank, Coloma, was to be reopened late this week following an order by Judge Charles E. White terminating the receivership. A court order also was issued recently at Caro for the reopening of the State Savings Bank of Caro. R. E. Reichert, state banking commissioner, states that the Bay City Bank is in a condition to reopen at any time. This statement followed completion of an analysis and appraisal of the bank's assets. The depositors' committee of the Benton Harbor State Bank is within $100,000 of its goal in securing depositors' signatures to a reorganization plan. Forty per cent of the required amount of $850,000 of the deposits of the closed Clare County Savings Bank, Clare, has been signed to agreements for the bank's reorganization and reopening. Nearly $250,000 was paid out in dividends recently to depositors in three closed Michigan banks. H. R. Botkin, receiver, First National Bank, of Buchanan, closed last October, made a 45 per cent dividend distribution totaling $190,000 to 1,400 depositors. Depositors of the defunct State Bank, of Freeport, are receiving a 15 per cent dividend. W. R. Lobdell is receiver. The payment will total $31,100. A ten per cent dividend was distributed this week to depositors of the defunct Bridgman State Bank, closed in December 1930, by T. F. Gore, receiver. The payment totals about $27,000. The Bridgman bank has thus far paid out 30 per cent. A court hearing will be held befor Circuit Judge E. C. Pugsley, to facilitate liquidation of assets of the defunct Churchill and Webber private bank at Shelby. A plan has been proposed by which creditors would be able to obtain 20 per cent of general claims by actual purchase of notes, mortgages and security assets of the bank or by payments of cash as an alternative. The plan provides for the sale of the bank's assets at public auction. He came back a few days later and before the. officials could single him out again he had gotten on the outside of a few more free meals. Finally the county board agreed to appropriate money for the feeding of the indigent army. After that, it didn't last long. The last straw was reached when the men refused to help the city clear a municipal park. Shortly after the law was laid down. The bums had to go or something unpleasant would happen. Today men are living in jungles near the city. They are seldom seen on the streets. They do not molest anyone. The only time they ever were a nuisance was when the good people of Iron River tried to help them out. Iron River today has resumed its usual trend of life. Today We do not rub elbows with filthy bums. We are not accosted on every corner. The city hall is a clean building once again and the sidewalk in front of it may be walked over dry-shod. Better forget about the soup kitchen and flop house, Menominee.Iron River Reporter.


Article Text

COMMENCE SUITS FOR ASSESSMENTS LEVIED BANK STOCK Merlin president of the closed Benton Harbor State bank. and wife, Marian M. Resch. were named defendants in three suits filed Berrien circuit court today Arthur Foeltzer. for the bank. The three filed by Gray. attorney for the receiver Each suit was filed to collect the per cent stock 150 shares of the bank stock held Resch and his wife Resch named defendant in one suit collect the 108 shares held in his own name, ued $10,800 Mrs. Resch was named defendant the second suit collect shares stock she held in her own name, she alleged have transferred to her husband less than week before the bank closed December third filed against both the president the bank and wife to collect eight shares stock valued $800, which they held jointly. which was transferred Resch than week before the closed. According the declarations. the receiver claims the transfer the shares from Mrs. Resch her and the eight shares held jointly to the husband, are void.


Article Text

REOPENING OF BENTON HARBOR BANK APPROVED Receiver for Institution Also Dismissed by Judge White Reopening of the Benton Harbor State bank given clear track this morning Circuit Judge Charles White approved the depositors' agreement granted their petition discharge the receiver. objections to the plan were filed. Announcement of the date of will be made within week, opening


Article Text

HARBORITE SUED FOR BANK ASSESSMENT Frank Moore, Benton Harbor fruit backage dealer, named defendsuit filed today in Berrien county circuit court by Arthur Foeittemporary receiver for the BenHarbor State bank. The was filed collect $800 assessment the Benton Harbor man for eight shares of stock the State Bank he held at the time the institution closed last year. Attorney H. Gray represents the receiver.


Article Text

COURT BERRIEN COUNTY DIVIDEND second local bank dividend will be paid shortly following order issued by Circuit Judge Charles E. White today authorizing the payment of 20 percent dividend by W. Worth Bean, Jr., receiver for the Berrien County bank. few days ago Mr. Bean received notice approval loan by the Reconstruction Finance corporation. He immediately applied for court order for payof the dividend. Today the American National Bank Trust company receiver, Payne, started raying 25 percent dividend to deThe total being paid by the American National is $367,153. Reopening of the Benton Harbor State bank was given clear track this morning when Circuit Judge Charles White approved the depositors' agreement and granted their petition to discharge the receiver. No objections to the plan were filed. Announcement of the date of reopening will be made within week, Grant H. Longenecker, chairman of the depositors' committee, announced following the He explained that considerable detail remains to be worked out before the bank can open, but said would open within the next three weeks The hearing this morning was conducted by Sid Erwin, assistant state attorney general in charge of banking matters. Three Witnesses Called Only three witnesses were called, County Clerk Benjamin H. Bittner, Arthur Foeltzer, receiver, and Harold Hudson, bank examiner from the state banking department The hearing took than half an hour The decree will be prepared immediately and submitted to Judge White for his signature This the last legal necessary the reopening of the bank, closed since last Clerk Bittner testified that no objections to the reopening plan had been filed in the circuit court. Receiver Foeltzer also testified that no objections had been filed with him. He said the depositors agreement had been signed 89 percent of the total deposit liability. No Illegal Withdrawals After testifying relative to the assets and liabilities of the bank, ceiver Foeltzer stated that no irregular illegal withdrawals by officers had been made for period of 60 days prior to its closing last December. He said the state banking department had approved the depositors plan. Examiner Hudson took the stand and said he had examined the bank and found that it had the sufficient $98,539 necessary reserve require- (Please turn to Page Six) Try The Troy Laundry. Dial 8711 Quality work and Let Inman Rent your


Article Text

Berrien County BENTON registraBenton Harbor voters passed the mark Friday, City Clerk said. Ninety-nine persons filed their names bring the total to date 5,025. There are only four days in which to the primary 13, which promises to be the most hotly contested in years. This year's registration made necessary by new permanent tration law, which requires that their names living in munities of over 5,000 Benton one the few townships the law. BENTON Moore, Benton Harbor fruit package named defendant filed Berrien county circuit court Arthur Foeltzer, receiver for the Benton Harbor State bank. The suit was filed collect $300 assessment the Benton Harbor for eight shares of stock of the State bank held the time institution closed last year. Attorney Gray represents receiver. group Baroda Interested, supporting ernor Franklin Roosevelt for president, met the home Mrs. Ladwig Thursday night, electing Ladwig president of tem porary organization. Other temporary officers are: Mrs. Shafer, vice president: Mrs. Adeline Nelthorpe, and Mary Shafer, treasurer. The meeting was charge of Ed Burton, Berrien county demowho one of the speakers. The group was addressed Mrs. Minerva Olson, Joseph. secretary of Berrien county democratic committee. Mrs. Kaltenbrun, state organizer democratic women, took charge of temporary officers. nearly completed where four threshing outfits have been in operafor several weeks. Many


Article Text

Reopening Plans for Benton Harbor State Bank Are Announced HARBOR, Mich., Aug. and director the new Ben- ton Harbor State today by Grant H. chairman of the committee that con ducted the campaign for re-organizing the bank. President of the bank will be Charles Conkey, Benton Harbor grocery cashier will be Fisher, formerly of Chicago. will Include Mr. Conkey, Mr. ClarDean, undertaker: Smith, estate man: and Sutherland Thomas Lynch, both whom farmers. dismissal of the receiver, was granted in the Berrien county circuit court late day by Circuit Judge Charles White. was the last obstacle the way of re-opening the bank. Both the cashier and the president financial institution are experienced in banking. Mr. Conkey nephew the late Conkey, first president of the Farmers


Article Text

White Authorizes Two Closed Banks to Make Postal Fund Payments Two orders were signed by Judge Charles White in Berrien county circuit court today authorizing payment of postal deposits in two closed banks in Berrien county. This the third order Judge White has signed granting the payments of postal deposits as preferred claims. The orders signed today grant the payment of postal deposits the Benton Harbor State bank to the Benton Harbor postmaster. The tition order were approved Attorney H. Gray, who represents the bank. The second order granted the paythe "Postmaster Money Order Account' in the Buchanan State bank to the postmaster general, petition approved the of Burns Hadsell, which represents the bank receiver. Two months ago the court granted order payment posdeposits in the Stevensville bank.


Article Text

TWO MORE BANKS ORDERED TO PAY POSTAL DEPOSITS Two orders signed by Judge Charles White the Berrien county cuit court today grant payment of postal deposits in two closed banks in Berrien county This the third order granting the payments postal deposits preferred claims signed by Judge White. The orders signed today grant the payment of postal deposits in the Benton Harbor State Bank the Benton Harbor postmaster petition and order approved by Attorney Gray, who represents the bank. The second order granted the payment of of "Post master Money Order Account" in the Buchanan State Bank to the postmaster general, petition approved by the law firm of Burns Hadsell. which represents the bank receiver. Two months ago the court granted the order the postal posits in the Stevensville bank to be paid.


Article Text

BENTON HARBOR SUIT TO CASH IN CLOSED BANK ARGUED Trial of the suit brought by the board of Benton Harbor the Surety recover $40,000 school funds in the Benton Harbor State bank closed last December, was held Federal Judge Fred Raymond at Grand Rapids yesThe board of education is attemptthe money the bond City Treasurer George Larkworthy. The American Surety company on Treasurer Larkworthy's bond. The school funds the bank the time closed were excess of $46,000, but the bond was only for $40,000. Attorney Willard J. Banyon and Attorney S. Gray represented the board of education yesterday, while Attorneys Charles Farrell and Attorney Paulson of Kalamazoo, represented the surety company At conclusion the trial, Judge refused to rule on motion to dismiss, made by the surety company technical grounds, and ordered both sides to file briefs on the merits of the case. Those who testified included M. Hall, of the board of education. Frank W Dunbar, clerk of the school board, Larkworthy, and Olaf Brewitz, assistant cashier of the bank. Parents of Son Mr. and Mrs. Hauck, of Norwood, O., are the parents of son, born Oct. 26. The mother was the former Miss Helen Murphy of Benton Harbor, daughter Mrs. 775 Lavette street, who at the Hauck home for few weeks Is III in Dowagiac Mrs. Irving Hogue, formerly of Fair avenue, Benton Harbor, is seriously at the home of her daughter, Mrs. Clara Graber, in Dowagiac


Article Text

BENTON HARBOR STATE BANK TO PAY 10 PER CENT $38,000 Trust Fund Dividend Will Be Available Thursday There is more good news for twin city bank depositors today! Dwight M. Ruth, cashier of the Benton Harbor State bank, announced this forenoon that starting tomorrow that institution will begin payment of $38,000, representing 10 per cent of the deposits held in trust under terms of the reorganization agreement adopted by the depositors. The current dividend will be the first involving trust deposits, Mr. Ruth explained. The bank has achieved an enviable record by completing payment of all moratorium deposits in two and a half years, although the agreement did not call for completion of moratorium payments until September 1, 1937. Profits to Depositors Mr. Ruth emphasized today that all profits accruing to the bank have gone back to depositors and will continue to do so until the trust deposits are paid out in full. Additional trust dividends will be paid as rapidly as possible. Yesterday W. R. Payne, receiver for the Commercial National Bank & Trust company of St. Joseph announced that the bank there would pay a 12ยฝ per cent dividend to all holders of receivers' certificates. This is the third commercial dividend since that institution closed in September, 1931, and brings dividend payments to depositors up to 50ยฝ per cent. Mr. Payne also revealed that the American National Bank & Trust company, Benton Harbor, will pay another dividend early next year.