Idaho State Bank (Hailey, ID)

Episode Information

Episode UID
8927419991329
Episode Type
Suspension → Closure
Bank Type
state
Bank ID
892741999 hash
Start Date
September 1, 1910
Location
Hailey, Idaho (43.520, -114.315)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini (chosen from majority vote of a three-model LLM ensemble)
Short Digest
b6662062565b0e66

Response Measures

None

Description

Later criminal conviction of the bank's vice president Leo Cramer for actions tied to the bank's insolvency is reported.

Events (2)

1. September 1, 1910 Suspension
Cause
Bank Specific Adverse Info
Cause Details
Ill-advised loans and hypothecated collateral largely worthless (loans to officers and related parties), producing insolvency.
Newspaper Excerpt
the little city of Hailey, Idaho, is roughly aroused over the sudden se of the Idaho State bank of Hailey. The bank closed its doors Wednesday ... the affairs of the bank are in a tangled condition
Source
newspapers
2. September 5, 1910 Receivership
Newspaper Excerpt
Hal Coffin, of Boise, a stockholder in the institution, has been appointed receiver. Bank Examiner Cruse declares that none of the depositors will lose.
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (13)

Article from The Salt Lake Tribune, September 3, 1910

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

aho State Bank of That Place Suddenly Collapses and Closes Doors. LLATERAL SAID TO BE PRACTICALLY WORTHLESS lieved That Depositors Will Lose Virtually All of Their Money. "he little city of Hailey, Idaho, col- is roughly aroused over the sudden se of the Idaho State bank of Hailey. 3 bank closed its doors Wednes - and is now in the hands of State nk Examiner G. W Cruse of Boise 3 affairs of the bank are in a tangled dition, and it will probably be a g time before they are straightened ractically all of the collateral held is the bank as security for loans assets a to be worthles, so that the the bank amount to little or nothing e total liabilities, consisting amount largely money owing to depositors, almost $500,000. rom present indications, the loss total. to depositors will be practically , failure of the bank will undoubtedcause a depression in the prosperous take amunity from which it will of e time to recover. The effects farfailure, however, will not be banks ching. as there are no other Camas busines houses involved. The by irie bank of Soldier was owned Idaho State bank, but just the before failure it was taken over by iley National bank, and is in good dition. Ill-Advised Loans Responsible. 'he failure of the bank is said to e been largely due to all ill-advised ns and investments Practically and , the Cramer, collateral securities is said were to vice-president be and hypothecated worthless. general hager of the bank, was the principal the ckholder. The investments of k consisted largely of loans to Mr. mer and his brother, who invested money in projects that at best gave V hough returns. the bank has been shaky for e time, its condition was not genIly known. Word reached Salt in Lake Sunday night that the bank was ilous condition, and J. B. Na- Cosgriff, e-president of the Continental al bank of Salt Lake, and a stockler in the Hailey National, left Salt e for Hailey. The Hailey National it to the assistance of the distressed k and helped it to keep open on nday. Advantage was taken of the t that Tuesday was primary election in Idaho, and the banks were closed that day. After the exact condi1 of the bank was learned on Tuesthe state bank examiner was sent The bank was opened on Wednesand business carried on as usual. - depositors were kept in the dark to the bank's condition, and there 75 uodn una ou : Camas Prairie Bank Saved. he result of the investigation, howr. showed that there was no pose way to save the bank, and its irs were turned over to the state k examiner. The bank was not rened on Thursday. In the meantime state bank examiner planned to e the Camas Prairie bank at Sol:. At the request of the state bank miner, J. B. Cosgriff purchased of the ** of that bank, the control ch had been held by the Idaho te bank, and the reserve of $43,000 transferred from the Idaho State the Hailey National. t the time the state bank State examiner bank


Article from The Morning Standard, September 4, 1910

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANK AT HAILEY FAILS TO OPEN The little city of Halley, IJaho, is over sudden thoroughly aroused the bank of bank its doors Hailey. collapse of The the Idaho closed State Wednesday and is now in the hands of G. W. Cruse Boise. State Bank The Examiner affairs of the bank of are in a tangled condition, and it will probably be a long time before they are straightened out. of held Practically the bank all security the collateral by as for loans is said to be worthless, so that the assets of the bank amount to little or nothing The total liabilities, consisting largely of money owing to depositors, amount to almost $500,000 loss to From the depositors present indications, will be practically the total. will cause a in the undoubtedly The failure of depression the bank prosperous community from which it will take some time to recover. The effects of the failure, however, will not be far-reaching, as there are no other banks or business houses involved The Camas Prairie bank of Soldier was owned by the Idaho State bank, but just before the failure it was taken over by the Halley National bank, and is in good condition. III-Advised Loans Responsible The failure of the bank 18 said to have been largely due to ill-advised loans and investments. Practically all of the securities were hypothecated and its collateral is said to be worthess. Leo Cramer, vice president and general manager of the bank, was the principal stockholder. The investments of the bank consisted largely of loans to Mr. Cramer and his brother, who invested the money in projects that at best gave slow returns. Though the bank has been shaky for some time. its condition was not Salt Lake on that bank generally Sunday known night Word reached the was and of the ConCosgriff, in perllous vice president condition, J. B. tinental National bank of Salt Lake, and a the NaThe tional, left stockholder Salt Lake in for Halley, Hailey bank asand sistance Hailey National of the distressed went bank to the on Monday was taken of the fact that helped Advantage It to keep open Tuesday was primary election day in were closed on exact condiIdaho, that day and the After banks the tion Tuesof the the state bank bank was learned examiner on day was sent for. The bank was on and as were Wednesday usual, The depositors business carried opened kept on in the dark as to the bank's condition, and there was no run upon it. Camas Prairie Bank Saved. The result of the investigation, however, showed that there was no possible way to save the bank, and its affairs were turned over to the state bank examiner. The bank was not reopened on Thursday. In the meantime the bank examlner save Prairie of planned bank at to Soldier. state the At the Camas request state J. B. Cosstock of the griff purchased the bank examiner. the that bank. control of which had been held by the Idaho State bank, and the reserve of $43,000 was trans. ferred from the Idaho State to the Hailey National examiner of State At took the time charge the state the Idaho bank bank the deposits were $112,000 in open accounts: $41,000 in savings accounts and $155,000 in time accounts. An additional liability of about $200.000 was occasioned by the hypothecation of the securities. The total assets consisted of $76 in the vaults, and a large amount of collateral, the value of which is problematical, but belleved to be very slight. The last annual statement of the bank gives its capital stock as $75.000, surplus $13,000, deposits $434,000 and loans $343,000. Since that statement the deposits have shrunk approximately $100,000. J. J. Plummer was the president of the Ill-fated bank: Leo Cramer, vice president and manager: F. M. Coleman, cashier, and W. D. Cutts, assistant cashier.


Article from Daily Capital Journal, September 5, 1910

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

IDAHO STATE BANK AT HAILEY IS CLOSED [UNITED PRESS LEASED WIRE.] Boise, Idaho, Sept. 5.-Although it is generally believed that the Idaho state bank at Hailey was closed owing to certain transactions involving $136,000 worth of securities between the bank and an insurance company, State Bank Examiner Cruse today refused to discuss the nature of the transactions. Hal Coffin, of Boise, a stockholder in the institution, has been appointed receiver. Bank Examiner Cruse declares that none of the depositors will lose. The liabilities of the bank are given as $475,000. It is capitalized at $75,000.


Article from Shoshone Journal, September 9, 1910

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

IDAHO STATE BANK OF HAILEY CLOSES ITS DOORS. Receiver Appointed Who is Now at Work On the Books, H. N. Coffin, the receiver of the Idaho State Bank, who was appoint ed by Judge Walters, arrived from Boise Saturday and assumed charge of the duties of his office this mort ing. says the Wood River Times of Hailey. He said that he is too unfamiliar with the affairs of the bank to form an opinion regarding the outcome. Furthermore, that as he left for Hailey at two hours' notice he will in a day or two have to return to Boise for a day or so to attend to pressing business matters that cannot be managed by wire or letter. It will take the receiver about a week to familiarize himself with of the duties of his office this mornably another week to prepare a report of its condition that can be sworn to in court. That done the receiver will be able to say when he can begin paying off the depositors. As money is collected he will declare dividends as frequently as possible. But the bank may be reorganized, as that is manifestly the thing to do. The bank's business is established and it is Loo valuable an asset to be allowed to be lost if it


Article from The Salt Lake Tribune, November 23, 1911

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

HO BANKER MUST DO TIME IN PRISON preme Court Affirms Verdict in the Case of Leo Cramer of Hailey. relal to The Tribune. DISE. Ida., Nov. 22.--Leo Cramer. eely vice president of the Idaho bank of Halley, must serve an inirale sentence in the state peniThis is the edict of the suLery court of Idaho in an opinion it ted down today in the case of the of Idaho VS. Leo Cramer. appealed the verdict of guilty in the Fourth dal district. which is affirmed The is one of the most celebrated state Her cases that has originated in Idaho state bank of Hailey was one of the most prosperous inIn tions years Blaine controlled county, by and the Cramers. its stock Mitually the over a year was ent Investigation to wall made officers by of the ago Blaine state and examiner and with the result that John J. president: Leo Cramer, vice er ent: Arthur B. Cutts, cashier. and Cramer, a director of the bank. arrested. chaged with accepting a on August 31. 1910. from one Foster when they knew that the was insolvent. The act was classithe information as having been unlawfully, feloniously and mly. velently executed with the intent to Cramer was the first of the four to be tried. The trial took place at and proved to be of a sensational acter. exposing the insolvency of the Cramer was convicted and sento serve an indeterminate term in cententlary. appeal was immediately filed in ease and it was carried to the sucourt. James E. Babb counsel one of the defendants in the Idaho Bank of Commerce case of Walappeared in the case as a friend court. filing a brief in which he ed certain law points involving the Avency of a bank and the liability of directors. but the court held CraUA bank officer was criminally llawhether he received the deposit in or not. court récites the facts in the case. that the evidence showed that day the cashier, received the $40 deand entered upon the books by that on September 1. or three days sing. the bank failed to open its and since then the institution has in the hands of a receiver Leo was active manager and in conthe bank up to that time


Article from The Salt Lake Tribune, November 29, 1911

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

MER BEGINS HIS PRISON SENTENCE ad of Idaho Banking House Convicted for Action of a Teller. PLOYE TOOK DEPOSIT ad of Banking House Convicted for Action of a Teller. dal to The Tribune OISE. Ida., Nov. 28.-Leo Cramer, president and active manager of the the State bank of Hailey. defunct, is an inmate of the Idaho state penitiary. His sentence is from six the to two years and unless the apcation for a review of his case now ling before the supreme court is nted he must serve the sentence for full time if the beard of pardons not Interfere. Tamer entered Idalto's penal institulast Saturday night. None of the 1 formalities connected with the retion of prisoners at the penitentlary te suspended for him. He was given 1862. shown a cell and will remain quiet inmate until the officials have nded the occupation for which he is at Stted. Tamer had been identified with Idaho king institutions for many years and Hosely connected. through relationship many prominent people. both in this and many parts of the state. His is peculiar in that his conviction was uted under a statute of this state ich no other state in the union has. it holds that a director or officer of bank actively engaged in its manageat CRD be held guilty of having rered a deposit when the bank was Inrent. although the deposit Itself was tually received by another. This tute was enacted In 1905 and it is thout a precedent anywhere Teller Accepted Deposit. The Idaho State bank closed its doors tember 1. 1910. On August 31 of that Mr. while the bank was open and coneting business as usual Helen Foster, of the customers of the bank. desited $10 with Teller Arthur B. Cutts. Her the bank closed the next day. and then an investigation was made by the late bank examiner. Cramer and Cutts more arested on the charge of accepting Reposits in an insolvent bank and with be knowledge at the time the deposit (1.8 received that the bank was defunct. ugh Cramer a director, and John J. lumer. president, were also placed unarrest. Leo Cramer elected to be fed first and was convicted in the diset court. He appealed to the supreme mrt, but the high triounal of this state fused to remand the case and affirmed to judgment of the lower court sending ramer to prison. Application for a reearing of the case was Immediately


Article from The Richfield Recorder, December 28, 1911

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

RECEIVER DISCHARGED Idaho State Bank Creditors Know How Much They Lose. Fred Browwn, late receiver ffor the defunct Idaho State Bank, of Hailey, has made his final report, and has been discharged to take up his new duties as National Bank Examiner. courts, which affects a llarge sum There is one suit pending in the of money claimed by Mrs. Milller of Bellevue, on which a report can not be made untill it is settled in the courts. Should this be decided inn favor of the bank, the deposito will receive about 68 per cent of other way, depositors will receive only about 37 per cent. A payment on account is expectMay, when ten per cent willl be dised to be made aboout the first of tributed among the creditors. The real estate and other long-time securities will be availlable lalter, but not nearly at their face values. While the work off winding up the bank's affairs is practically COL pleted, Ech. Daft of Hailey was appointed to oversee the final distribution of the assets. lo


Article from Shoshone Journal, February 9, 1912

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

a MORE LOCAL DOPE Joe Culbertson was up from the Dietrich tract Wednesday. 8 Mrs. Daniels has returned from the hospital in Boise where she has been receiving treatment for on some time past. She has returned in quite good health. E. E. Daft of Hailey, newly appointed receiver of the Idaho State bank, was in Shoshone on Tuesday on business connected with the defunct institution. Mr. Daft is making a great effort to collect the indebtedness owed to the bank and hopes to be able to pay a dividend within a few months. Sam Malicoat and wife were in town Wednesday and Thursday from their place in the northern part of the coun'v. Mr. Malicoat is one of the best coyote and bob cat trappers in Southern Idaho, and during this winter has sold the pelts from several hundred of these animals. Last Saturday both boys and girls basket ball teams piled into wagons and drove to Richfield to try their skill against the renowned heavers of that beautiful berg. The next day a sleepy and delapidated aggregation returned and reported a victory for the boys of 15 to 13. The girls, however, were defeated by a narrow margin. It is stated that the advance agents of the wool buyers have already made their appearance and I are offering good prices for this year's clip. It is thought that wool will bring seventeen cents or e better this spring which is conb siderable advance over the prices that wool brought last season. Whittington & Millsaps pool hall 8 was filled Wednesday night until to there wasn't a chance for even a P P mouse to get in edgewise, with men n who turned out to see Fred B. It Hall do some fancy stunts at pool fi playing and juggling pool balls. Many of the best pool players pres18 ent pronounced Mr. Hall's exhibia tion the finest they had ever witt nessed. g to Sheriff Zug has returned from a E rip to Boise where he was suboenaed as a witness before the W Federal Grand Jury. While in per Boise he was waylaid at every turn g 80 and asked how his delegation of bootleggers were getting along as guests of his county. He was assured that no new colony of law


Article from Shoshone Journal, August 22, 1913

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Miss Stella Cook, county superintendent, is spending today in Gooding. WANTED-Clean old rags at the Journal office. Will pay two cents a pound. * * * Mr. and Mrs. J. W. Newman returned to Shoshone today.-Wood River Times. Hail Horne and wife visited with relatves in Haley for three days the latter part of last week. Bert Fink, Alviah C. Thompson and W. G. Park were visitors from Geeding on Thursday morning. J. W. Robertson was up from Gooding yesterday afternoon lookin after business and visiting frineds. Mrs. Nellie Johnson of Haddock was visiting in Shoshone the fore part of the week with Mrs. Sullivan E. Daft was a visitor from Hailey on yesterday. Mr. Daft is receiver of the defunet Idaho State bank at that place. The piano offered in contest by The Morse Store is priced in the The Morse Store is priced at $225 and is the same grade that commands from $300 to $400 at music stores. * W. G. Bissell, one of Gooding's leading attorney came up to Shoshone Monday on legal business and incidently took in the circus while here. * Mr. and Mrs. W. Haile Horne came up from Shoshone today to visit with their parents up here unil Monday.-Wood River Times of August 15. * Sa Society, Lodges, Churches, Sunel lay `Schools, Public Schools may hi ompete for the piano offered in $5 onlest by the Morse Store. No le one Barred. m pa The chapel car St. Peter will get sa Shoshone Saturday August 30th nd will hold services on the 31st pa M1 losing on September 7th. Everyin ody cordially invited. e * * bil Thomas Wolfe and Beckett of the att tockgrowers Mercantile Co., made ed flying trip to Ketchum Sunday. W ley report having a splendid time 18. th the exception of such unoidable accidents as will happen an auto. bac


Article from The Caldwell Tribune, September 19, 1913

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Depositors Sue for Damages. The depositors of the defunct Idaho State Bank of Hailey have brought suit against the American Surety Co. for damages in the sum of $50,000.00, the amount of the company's bond as surety for State Bank Examiner William Cruse. It is alleged that by reason of the failure of the state examiner to do his duty, the depositors lost their money, and the surety company is responsible. The specific charge is that on the 31st day of August, 1910, William G. Cruse, "knowing the said Idaho State Bank to be insolvent, in violation of law, allowed, permitted, sanctioned, approved and directed, the transfer, sale, assignment and disposal of certain notes, bonds, mortgages, and other securities, of the value of $43,500.00 to the Hailey National bank, J. E. Cosgriff and H. D. Curtis, and other persons whose names are unknown to this plaintiff, for the use and benefit or the Camas Prairie State bank and the said William G. Cruse thereby and by means thereof deprived the said depositors of the said Idaho State bank of their lien on all of the assets of the Idaho State bank and of the proceeds thereof." The plaintiffs hold that the state bank examiner knew the bank to be insolvent and that he should have applied for the appointment of a receiver. Failing to do this he neglected to do his duty and his bondsmen are liable.


Article from Shoshone Journal, January 16, 1914

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

New Set of Receivers for Hailey Bank. The members of the advisory board of the Idaho State bank at Hailey will henceforth act as joint receivers of the concern, succeeding E. Daft. who has served for the last several months as receiver. Judge E. A. Walters met last Monday with the board and accepted the resignation of Mr. Daft, after which the members of the board were named joint receivers. The new receivers are William Leonard, of Soldier: Dr. E. W. Kleinman and Joseph W. Fuld of Halley, Mr. Fuld is empowered to receive all money and pay bills of the institution.


Article from Evening Capital News, July 10, 1914

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

LEGAL NOTICE Proposal for Bids to Close Receivership Sealed bids will be received up to 5 p. m., Aug. 15th, 1914, for the following 200 acres of land (less R. R. right of way, 6.66 acres), located near Homedale, Owyhee county, Idaho: S½, SW½, Sec. 24; N½, NW½, Sec. 25; NW½. NE%, Sec. 25, Twp. 4N, Range 6W. Together with ample water right represented by $1680.00 bonds in the Gem Irrigation Dist. Each bid must be accompanied by cash or certified check amounting to 2 per cent of price bid. The receivers reserve the right to reject any and all bids. Money or check will be returned to unsuccessful bidders. Bids will also be received on the same basis as above for the whole or any part of 150 shares of stock in the Idaho State Life Insurance Co. Address, RECEIVERS, Idaho State Bank, Hailey, Idaho.


Article from Evening Capital News, July 25, 1914

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

LEGAL NOTICE Proposal for Bids to Close Receivership Sealed bids will be received up to 5 p. m., Aug. 15th, 1914, for the following 200 acres of land (less R. R. right of way, 6.66 acres), located near Homedale, Owyhee county, Idaho: S½, SW½, Sec. 24; N½, NW½, Sec. 25: NW½. NE%, Sec. 25, Twp. 4N, Range 6W. Together with ample water right represented by $1680.00 bonds in the Gem Irrigation Dist. Each bid must be accompanied by cash or certified check amounting to 2 per cent of price bid. The receivers reserve the right to reject any and all bids. Money or check will be returned to unsuccessful bidders. Bids will also be received on the same basis as above for the whole or any part of 150 shares of stock in the Idaho State Life Insurance Co. Address, RECEIVERS, Idaho State jim Bank, Hailey, Idaho.