Pacific Bank (San Francisco, CA)

Episode Information

Episode UID
9839053091117
Episode Type
Suspension β†’ Closure
Bank Type
trust
Bank ID
983905309 hash
Start Date
January 1, 1893*
Location
San Francisco, California (37.780, -122.419)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini (chosen from majority vote of a three-model LLM ensemble)
Short Digest
2ec62a6b02d405de

Response Measures

None

Description

Dates of collapse/receiver activities are inferred from letters dated Jan–Feb 1893; failure clearly described thereafter.

Events (3)

1. January 1, 1893* Receivership
Newspaper Excerpt
He had the unenvied honor of being the receiver of the bank for two hours. He never obtained actual possession and was thrown out to be succeeded by others.
Source
newspapers
2. January 1, 1893* Suspension
Cause
Bank Specific Adverse Info
Cause Details
Large-scale insider manipulation, fraudulent loans and dissipated funds (Sherman/Farnum/McDonald schemes) made the bank insolvent.
Newspaper Excerpt
When the end came he resigned his position, under instructions, and retired from the bank. Almost instantly, through the agency of Moses H. Sherman, Farnum was replaced.
Source
newspapers
3. November 15, 1898 Other
Newspaper Excerpt
The board of directors of the defunct Pacific bank at San Francisco declared dividend No. 8 of 5 per cent.
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (6)

Article from The San Francisco Call, November 14, 1898

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

D. S. Dorn, A. F. Johns and M. H. Sherman were not only in the business of silencing some dishonest newspapers, but of corruptly influencing Bank Commissioners in the great plot to ruin the Pacific Bank and the People's Home Savings Bank. The letters of Sherman that are published this morning prove the charge. Over his own signature M. H. Sherman has confessed that he schemed to influence the official action of Bank Commissioners W. H. Knight and Charles Dunsmore. This plot was one of the most shameless in the whole history of the bank wreckers' conspiracy. Two months before the crash came Sherman and his confederates thoroughly understood that any honest investigation of the condition of the banks would result in the closing of the institutions. They therefore plotted to procure a favorable report. Nothing could be done by the dishonest manipulators to influence the official action of A. Gerberd r. who was president at that time of the Bank Commission. The wreckers could not fight Mr. Gerberding and they could not corrupt him. They contrived therefore to deceive him if possible. This dishonest task was assigned to D. S. Dorn, and he was so successful in getting Mr. Gerberding out of the way that Sherman congratulated him for his efforts. Sherman also shows in his remarkable letters that the judgment of Bank Commissioner Dunsmore would be influenced by the fact that Mr. Dunsmore's brother-in-law had been given employment by Sherman. Bank Commissioner Knight was a close personal friend of Sherman, who craftily remarks in one of his letters that at a very critical time in the history of the tottering institutions he had dined at the home of Mr. Knight in Oakland. The schemer also took OCcasion to thank J. E. Farnum, the manager of the People's Bank, for warning the bank wreckers of the coming of the Commissioners. Farnum, who is now the manager of the defunct Pacific Bank, was a son-in-law of Bank Commissioner Knight, and through that relationship secured the information that was so valuable to the conspirators. The warning was given in time to permit the dishonest bankers to fix up their affairs with some semblance of honesty. The letters of Sherman that give these revelations to the public are of great importance, and prove the accusation of The Call that Moses H. Sherman was not only the chief agent in ruining the Pacific Bank and the People's Home Savings Bank, but knew it, and was as dishonest in his transactions at that time as were the McDonalds. Not only was Sherman interested in the Phoenix wildcat schemes and his gigantic Los Angeles deal, but he was very deeply involved in assisting other manipulators to keep up their drain on the banks. In one of his telegrams he hysterically begs Dick for God's sake not to dishonor the checks of O. T. Dyer. In another he assures Dick that they must all stand together, for any disaster at that time would ruin them all and their banks. In this assertion Moses H. Sherman very clearly indicates that he considered the dishonest institutions as much his property as they were that of the McDonalds. There is possibly no more interesting letter than one which is published this morning to show the remarkable audacity of Sherman and his confederates. In this epistle Sherman declares that the other bankers of this city, such as I. W. Hellman, Lovell White, Thomas Brown and others, did


Article from The Salt Lake Herald, November 15, 1898

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

TELEGRAPHIC BRIEFS. Delegates to the 22nd annual assembly of the Knights of Labor arrived in large numbers at Chicago. William Hickley Gross, archbishop of Oregon, Roman Catholic church, died at St. Joseph's hospital, Baltimore, of heart disease. Secretary Robert J. Thompson of Lafayette memorial committee has called the monument commission to meet in Chi. cago Nov. 26. Ex-Supervisor Clarke of Hoopestown, Ills., committed suicide with a revolver. He was the leading merchant of the city and a politician. Domestic trouble was the cause. Judge Samuel Owens, formerly an eminent jurist of Pennsylvania and after_ wards a resident of Iowa and California, died at Los Angeles of old age. He went to California in 1887. The board of directors of the defunct Pacific bank at San Francisco. declared dividend No. 8 of 5 per cent. The amount thus liquidated is about $32,000, and will make aproximately 80 per cent. Another trainload of alcohol, billed to Japan, has been sent west from Peoria. It will be used in the manufacture of smokeless gunpowder. There were 11 cars of 65 barrels each, or 62,920 gallons. Canonsburg, Pa., was visited by a bad fire, which wiped out fully a third of the, business portion, including two of the principal hotels and many dwellings, and did damage estimated at $100,000. No lives were lost. Sparks from a newly-lighted fire ignited the dress of Mrs. Preay, at Oakland, Cal., and she wus burned to death in the presence of her two small children. Just before her death she gave birth to a child, which was dead. The Turney & Jones Coal company of Columbus, O., and the Pennsylvania & Ohio Fuel company of St. Paul, both owned by the same parties, with offices in Chicago, were put into the hands of the Security & Title company of Chicago as receivers. Liabilities, $1,200,000.


Article from The San Francisco Call, November 17, 1898

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

alDonald and service was that ready the to dishonest perform old of financier most any requested. were on the verge transWhen the banks Frank McDonald valuable local to ferred destruction a piece of very to his father by the estate their to cheat McDonald real a bogus corporation family corporation belonging organized in turn the trans- credi- proptors. This back to Dr. McDonald old banker again Carferred erty transferred in question. the whose land The name to Horace these the transfers property W. pentier, recorded. in All illegal of and The com- Call is were now absolutely this morning the full and presents of this fact. of property plete evidence description Dr. the R. H. Mcis it stands be of Donald, Carpentier which The full although still owned by will in depositors the name inof Horace assistance W. to the what rightvaluable efforts to recover This property in their belongs to them. McDonald many in fully purchased by Dr. old man realized would was years later ago, days and of the San value. Francisco This it keep land to the above be of all tremendous others was he more wished than to particu- bogus lar in so that his name property in full as follows: himself, transactions transferring and he owner. it The through would a not appear description is point as on Market hunits street, Beginning on eleven the at southeast (111) feet side, and of one three Sanchez (3) dred and the corner southwesterly inches street, from and extending street for one at hundred right (150) feet; and to Market (110) feet; angles along fifty Market and ten street thence southwesterly Market thence one hundred and parallel to (150) feet; northeasterly hundred and fifty northwestat right and ten (110) a erly the point of at thence street one one hundred beginning. angles and point on feet the to beginning of Market street distant and southeasterly northeast Also of side previous feet piece, and four south- (4) inches eighty-eouthwesterly (83) of from Market southwest- the street of Market (8) along feet and and westerly erly Sanchez corner said street; (25) line thence and eight street at twenty-Av southeasterly one huninches; angles thence to Market feet; street thence northright dred and and ten parallel (110) with and said eleven Market and easterly fourteen (14) feet to the westerly one street; street street half Sanchez (11 1/2) inches thence sixteen north- (51/2) side of said Sanchez one half along five and and at erly (16) feet and thence Market northwesterly street ninety- to the seven right inches; angles (97) feet to and six (6) inches The by the point wrecked Call The placed of exposure beginning institutions the of creditors men on and their of women dishonesty the guard. who two money understood lost The their thousands McDonalds through that purpose the the made for any assured of exposure sensationalism. was not material They were advantage of the revelathat them something would result made, from and yesterday the tion to The Call the first has attachment H. McDonald upon in afternoon of Dr. R. This attachment property this issued city was in the made. McDonald. suit of S. G. The Murphy propagainst was R. H. street has been attach- of Mr. erty on Market legal representative to get by the now proceed Murphy, ed on who the defendant will sold by under publication judgservice the property the debts that and ment have to satisfy owes one of to the robbed McDonald banks. creditors Dr. of his of this year cashier S. G. Murphy, of the who In January at Bank, one time and was is now was president made the of First National of the depositors of Bank assignee the Pacific many Pacific Bank, Murphy Acting and creditors of the assignee Mr. in the capacity suit against of R. amount H. McDonald of several to filed a 50, the McDonald personally on bank. claims recover was sued assigned $34,842 of to the him. wrecked his Dr. liability stock- The as a stockholder man being the was principal first directed to old action was unable against him. on Dr. to the time serve holder, a legal summons Murphy along up McDonald was and the the suit death dragged of Daniel When Titus, The. who Call of its began measures that of and Murphy's startling attorney. expose accomplished Bank, the Murphy, men the Pacific on the among ruin of thousands the of others, was


Article from The San Francisco Call, November 27, 1898

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

in Tragic Story of a Day the Affairs of the Banks. The McDonalds Ordered to Give Up One Hundred Thousand Dollars in Coin. and Farnum and Sherman won out, and of In its expose of the shameless robto-day Mr. Farnum is the manager beries that were committed in the name the Pacific Bank. of the People's Home Savings Bank As already indicated in The Call the and the Pacific Bank The Call has of association of Mr. Farnum with the mentioned incidentally the name the McDonalds began through Moses H. John E. Farnum. This man is Sherman. It was through the agency present manager of the now defunct of Sherman that Farnum was placed in Pacific Bank, and The Call proposes to of the bank as a servant and a willing tell what part he took in the ruin tool of the McDonalds. Before the asthe institutions in which thousands of sociations were closed Farnum became men and women and children had one of the most uncompromising conplaced their savings. spirators, who forced from the McDonMr. Farnum's connection with the alds the remaining funds of the banks. People's Home Savings Bank dates, as Late in 1892 and early in 1893 the Paalready indicated in The Call, from a cific Bank was sorely in need of funds very early period in the conspiracy. He and was depending solely upon the was placed in the People's Home SavPeople's Home Savings Bank for its ings Bank by his relative, M. H. Sherresources. Sherman's schemes had alman. He used the funds of the savings institution to assist his relative, Sherready made the banks insolvent, but the deluded people of this city were still man, in every scheme that demanded assistance. He was something more pouring their money into the People's Home Savings Bank. This institution than Dr. McDonald believed. He was was nothing more or less than a sieve not only a servant of the McDonalds, through which the savings of deposibut for several years he was the dictator of their affairs. He stooped to tors dropped into the vaults of the Pacific Bank to be dissipated in their wild every dishonorable duty they demanded, and then having the dishonest speculations. Farnum knew the situabankers in his power he commanded tion thoroughly and knew what was them to do what he pleased. He sent expected of him. He knew that as soon them money from the People's Home as money came into the People's Home Savings Bank in a golden stream to Savings Bank it was to be sent to the the Pacific Bank in order that his relaPacific Bank and he carried out his contract to the letter. tive, Moses H. Sherman, might receive it; and when this stream seemed likely One of his first important letters in to be stopped even by the McDonalds reference to this proposition was writhe commanded the bankers by delibten early in 1893 and is as follows: SAN FRANCISCO, January 7, 1893. erate and absolute threats to give what Mr. R. H. McDonald Jr., vice-presimoney they had left for the worthless dent Pacific Bank, San Francisco, securities of Sherman. Cal.-Dear Sir: I send per our mesAfter John E. Farnum was placed in senger this morning twenty thousand the People's Home Savings Bank as ($20,000) dollars in coin. manager he became the "stool pigeon" We have on hand little more than and outside guard of the conspiracy. we think we will need in payment of It was his duty to warn the bank recent dividends. Besides, loans are wreckers whenever the Bank Commisnot being applied for to any great exsioners threatened to descend upon tent, and we cannot afford to keep the cash on hand without getting any them. It was his privilege to tell them interest thereon. what the authorities were likely to do A year ago our board of directors As soon as the money of thousands of decided to have the rate of interest poor depositors was placed in the changed which your bank allowed us vaults of the People's Home Savings from six per cent to four and half Bank it was the duty of Farnum to per cent. with the expectation that the send it to the Pacific Bank. After both money would be available for loans institutions became insolvent this man and investments within six months thereafter. continued in control, and even when While we have gradually drawn the McDonalds wished to call a halt he down our balance, still is of such commanded them to continue their sum as not to be of moment to us: and depredations and to permit Moses H. if your bank can now allow us from the Sherman to foist his worthless securifirst of January five per cent on our upon the savings institution. daily balances I know it would be This terrible affair in which Farnum greatly appreciated by our directors. Please let me know if that meets played the leading part did not end with your favor, and will be glad to until long after the collapse of the Pabring the matter up before our board cific Bank and the People's Home Savat their next meeting. Yours truly, ings Bank. When Sherman found it J. E. FARNUM, Secretary. impossible to keep his relative in the The foregoing letter, which was writPeople's Bank he thrust Farnum upon ten by Farnum in January, 1893, was in the Pacific Bank, and there he remains measure somewhat formal. A month as the director and manager of what remains to the deluded and robbed and a week afterward Mr. Farnum creditors of the institution. wrote another letter in which he The events that are incidental to the showed clearly how the People's Home Savings Bank was being bled to susplacing of John E. Farnum in the Peotain the dying energies of the Pacific ple's Home Savings Bank and after that in the Pacific Bank are of timely Bank. The Call promised to prove that interest. Farnum was a member of the the People's Home Savings Bank was Legislature when the Bank Commissimply a feeder for the Pacific Bank, sioner act of this State was adopted. and in the following letter of John E. Farnum that promise is kept: As a member of the Legisiature Farnum possessed some influence, and SAN FRANCISCO, Feb. 15, 1893. with that influence he succeeded in R. H. McDonald Jr., Pacific BankDear Sir: Yours at hand, and in reply having himself made a member of the permit me to say that the R. Coal Bank Commission. In that capacity Company paid only a portion of their he became acquainted with the affairs loan yesterday, but expect to coland private doings of the banks of this lect in all of it this week if possible. State. He became connected with a send you $10,000 coin this a. m., and bank in Pasadena and familiarized will continue to send our surplus himself with banking methods. This money for our credit with you. Your was long before Sherman planned his apprehension as per your letter may tremendous raid on the People's Home be well founded, but do not look for anything of that nature, although it Savings Bank and the Pacific Bank. is well enough to be prepared. B. O. Carr, a brother-in-law of Moses do not know what your ideas are, H. Sherman, was the first manager of but presume there is to be limit the People's Home Savings Bank. Mr. to the amount that you expect to reCarr was an honest man and necessarceive from us and a time beyond which the special deposits are expected to ily was useless to Sherman. After cease. Please let me know about that Sherman became a director in the Paand oblige, yours truly. cific Bank in January, 1891. he succeedJ. E. FARNUM. ed in securing for his relative, Farnum, the position of manager of the People's Two months later affairs in the PeoHome Savings Bank. ple's Home Savings Bank and the PaThe McDonalds had at that time cific Bank were becoming critical. The enormous debt of the Pacific Bank was plunged into hazardous speculation. The funds of the Pacific Bank and the rapidly approaching $1,000,000, and, notwithstanding the compliance of the People's Home Savings Bank were beBank Commissioners, it was imperative ing dissipated in crazy schemes and unwarranted ventures. Sherman had something should be done. Farnum and Frank McDonald understood thoralready involved the McDonalds and their banks in his Phoenix schemes oughly that it was impossible to conand he was prepared to inveigle them tinue thedepredationsupon the People's Bank any longer, and a series of teleinto the great Los Angeles electric road deal. Farnum was necessary, therefore, grams passed between the conspirators. to the success of Sherman's plot and These telegrams show how clearly the the man who is now manager of the bank wreckers understood that they Pacific Bank was placed in full conwould have to settle their accounts in trol as manager of the People's Home the People's Bank. This, however, was Savings Bank. He had absolute power impossible, and affairs had drifted to in that position until the final collapse. such a stage that Farnum himself took When the end came he resigned his the reins and forced upon the dishonest position, under instructions, and rebankers the concluding outrages of tired from the bank. Almost instantly, Sherman. He not only insisted that through the agency of Moses H. SherSherman should be tolerated in his disman, Farnum was replaced. honest manipulations, but he planned The Call has already exploited the to foist upon the banks several more of scheme of the Los Angeles manipulaSherman's worthless loans. The chief tor to control the liquidation of the of these loans was in reference to the Electric Railroad of Phoenix, Ariz. People's Home Savings Bank. SherThis road, as The Call has already man had determined to protect his disreputable interests in the bank and shown, was built at an expense not exFarnum was selected as his agent. ceeding $35,000. With this investment Sherman floated a bond issue of $66.When Farnum was appointed as re000. These bonds the Los Angeles and ceiver, however, those who were interPhoenix manipulator foisted upon the ested in the honest closing of the bank Pacific Bank and the People's Home rebelled and Farnum had the unenviaSavings Bank. These two institutions ble honor of being the receiver of the as far as money was concerned were bank for two hours. He never obtained one. Sherman had Frank McDonald actual possession and was thrown out to be succeeded by others. absolutely under his control, and he had had his relative, John E. Farnum, Notwithstanding this tremendous dein the People's Bank. The McDonalds feat Sherman was persistent. He still had already given $66,000 for the bonds had the Bank Commission in his power of the Phoenix Railroad, which was and with the assistance of Attorney subsequently known as the Valley General Hart and others he placed FarStreet Electric Railroad. Sherman's num in the Pacific Bank as receiver. A series of legal complications followed agents, who happened to be dishonest


Article from Albuquerque Daily Citizen, July 28, 1899

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

ARIZONA TOPICS. Phoenix Street Railway Insolvent-Vavapai County Bonds, The Third district court of Arizona has ordered foreclosure of the bonds of the Phoenix street electric railway, issued at 6 per cent, in 1893, to the amount of $250,000. The debts now aggregate $356,427. The main creditor isthe receiver ofthe People's Home Savings bank of San Francisco, who holds 165 $1,000 bonds, on which no interest has been paid since 1894. These bonds were originally owned by the Pacific bank of San Francisco and figured prominently in the investigation made into the affairs of that institution after its failure. The main stockholder and president of the company 18 M. H. Sherman, formerly of Phoenix.


Article from The Daily Silver State, July 23, 1904

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

HAPPENINGS IN OUR OWN STATE Late News Notes Gathered From Many Places in Nevada While working at the Ward shaft yesterday a piece of casting fell on Charles Wilson and broke his leg between the ank!9 and knee. Mr. Wilson was taken to his home at the corner of F and Union streets and made as comfortable as possible. He had only started to work yesterday morning, after being idle a long time.-Enterprise. At the annual meeting of the stockholders of the Union Consolidated Mining company in San Francisco Tuesday the following directors were elected: C. H. Fish, C. Hirshfeld, A. F. Coffin, William Dannar and B. F. Shaw. C. H. Fish was elected president, C. Hishfeld vice president, A. P. Swain secretary and A. J. McDonnell superintendent. The Carson News is authorized to make the announcement that Hon. Samuel Platt, who served Ormsby county in the legislature, was the Republican party's nominee for attorney general at the last election and who has stumped the state several times in the interests of the Republican ticket, will be a candidate before the Republican convention at Winnemucca for the nomination of member of congress. An attempt was made late Thursday night to hold un Dr. Franck at the corner of Fourth and Virginia streets, says the Gazette. He says that as he was returning from the home of Prof. Krall, where he attended a musicale, he was accosted by two roughs, one of whom asked him what time it was and the other commanded him to turn over his valuables. The doctor was not in a mood to cc mply and the demand was not repeated. Monday evening, as the logging train of the Tahoe railroad was rounding a curve at the Tahoe Lumber company's camp en route to Truckee with a load cf logs, the engine struck Frank Pasini and Barney Bettanini, who were walking along the track, and instantly killed the former, while the !atter had his !eft leg run over, necessitating an amputation as soon as he could be brought to town. Pasini's head was nearly severed from the body.-Enterprise. The five Chinamen arrested at Beowawe the first of the week for being in the United States without entrance papers, were brought up before Commissioner T. J. Edwards at Carson Wednesday. It was found that four of them had the necessary papers and they were immediately released. The fifth .man's story is that he has the necessary document, but it is deposited in a safe place and he claims to have sent for it to present proof. If his story is straight he also will be released. Frank Meder and Fred Brown are making arrangements to put a steamboat on Washoe lake. They have secured the necessary engine and will be at work assembling the necessary outfit snortly. Washoe lake is increasing in popularity every season with those who wish a single day's outing, and some quick, pleasant method of crossing to the east side is what the sportsmen have been looking for. The little steamer will have all it can do on Sundays and other holidays and will shorten the time to the club house by nearly an hour.-Carson News. A story comes from Tonopah to the etfect that T. L. Oddie, general manager of the Tonopah Mining company and one of the wealthiest men in the new mining district, had engaged attorneys with a view to filing a suit for divorce against his wife from whom he separated several days ago. According to the report Oddie is in San Francisco conferring with his lawyers and is expected to institute proceedings in a few days. The ground upon which his suit will be based is said to be incompatibility of temper, although gossip has it that the couple have separated for more serious reasons. Mrs. Oddle was formerly Clara Belle McDonald, wife of Richard McDonald of San Francisco, whose connection with the sensational failure of the Pacific bank