Equitable Trust Company (Chicago, IL)

Episode Information

Episode UID
2033371272
Episode Type
Suspension β†’ Closure
Bank Type
trust
Bank ID
203337 routing
Routing Number
2-0333
Start Date
December 18, 1905
Location
Chicago, Illinois (41.850, -87.650)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini (chosen from majority vote of a three-model LLM ensemble)
Short Digest
d520f9d6a25b65ce

Response Measures

None

Description

Equitable Trust Company was one of three Walsh-controlled institutions that suspended and went into liquidation.

Events (1)

1. December 18, 1905 Suspension
Cause
Bank Specific Adverse Info
Cause Details
Heavy loans and investments in John R. Walsh's railroad, coal, quarry and other enterprises left the trust company insolvent and forced suspension/liquidation.
Newspaper Excerpt
The Chicago National, the Home Savings and the Equitable Trust Co., three banks controlled by Jno. R. Walsh, suspended operations on the 18th.
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (23)

Article from The Sun, October 25, 1903

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

LAKE STREET ELEVATED ROAD. Charges of Mismanagement Lead to the Application for a Receiver. CHICAGO. Oct. 24.-Charges of mismanagement and official neglect of property led to the appointment of a receiver this afternoon for the Lake Street Elevated Railroad Company. The bill of complaint on which the Equitable Trust Company was named by Judge Tuthill as receiver for the road was filed in the Circuit Court by James Bolton and Daniel F. Crilly as stockholders in the company. The bill saysthat the elevated railroad company is insolvent. In addition to this charge, it is asserted that in contracts entered into by the officials other lines have recelved advantages denied to the Lake road.


Article from Wausau Pilot, November 3, 1903

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

"L" Road in Trouble. The Chicago Lake Street Elevated Railroad Company passed into the hands of a receiver on the petition of two stockholders, who declared the corporation insolvent. Judge Tuthill appointed the Equitable Trust Company to take charge.


Article from The Montgomery Advertiser, November 17, 1903

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Bankruptcy Proceedings. Chicago, Nov. 16.-Bankruptcy proceedings against the Hannesberry Company, publishers, were started in the United States District Court Saturday, and the matter was kept secret until to-day. The Equitable Trust Company was appointed receiver for the assets of the concern. The liabilities of the corporation were not stated in the petition though the assets were placed at $150,000.


Article from The Saint Paul Globe, November 17, 1903

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Publishers in Trouble. CHICAGO, Nov. 16.-Bankruptcy proceedings against the Henneberry company, publishers, have been started in United States district court. The Equitable Trust company was appointed receiver. The liabilities of the corporation are not stated. The assets are placed at $150,000.


Article from The Roswell Daily Record, February 12, 1904

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

RECEIVER APPOINTED. Model Gold Mining Company Badly Entangled. Chicago, Feb. 12.-Upon petition of the stockholders alleging "fraudulent mismanagement" Judge Kohlsaat in the U. S. District Court today appointed the Equitable Trust Company receiver for the Model Gold Mining Company. The receivership follows the holding to the federal grand jury of Frank and John Jaeger, president and secretary of the company.


Article from New-York Tribune, January 15, 1905

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

APPETIZING DINNERS are offered by several restaurants to-day in the "Little Ads. of the People." ELEVATOR COMPANY BANKRUPT. Chicago, Jan. 14.-Upon the recommendation of Sidney C. Eastman, referee in bankruptcy, Judge Kohlsaat, in the United States District Court, yesterday entered an order of bankruptcy against the Chicago Terminal Elevator Company, which has contested the issuing of such an order for a year. The Equitable Trust Company was appointed receiver. The obligations of the company are said to be $3,500,000, with $1,000,000 in first mortgages and $2,500,000 in bonds, issued ten years ago. The company appealed from Judge Kohlsaat's order.


Article from The Topeka State Journal, December 18, 1905

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

FINANCIAL CRASH CHICAGO ties include $2,707,563. of which amount $454,000 are deposits in trust National Bank, a Savings Bank and $500,000 in certificates of deposit. and a Trust Company The Chicago National bank has been an active factor in local politics for several years, and the enormous funds received from the taxation for the buildBrought Down in a Heap by ing and maintenance of the drainage canal have been a part of its deposits Comptroller Ridgley. and have been available for investment by the bank. A change was recently made in the political complexion of the LIABILITIES board and it was understood that these TOTAL funds would not remain for any length of time as deposits in the Chicago National bank. Their impending withAre Roughly Estimated at 26 drawal had much to do with the fear of the other banks of a far reaching Million Dollars. collapse if they did not come to the aid of the weakened institutions. Walsh's Operations. Assets of Three Institutions The enterprises which are generally credited with being the indirect cause Placed at $20,000,000. of the financial troubles of Mr. Walsh are the Bedford Quarries company of Indiana, and the Southern Indiana Railroad company, which was conTO BE TAKEN CARE OF. structed by Mr. Walsh for the purpose of getting the stone from his quarries to the market. This railroad was conOther Banks Promise to Provide structed by Mr. Walsh at a heavy expense some years ago, because he befor the Shortage. lieved that the Monon railroad, which was the only outlet of his stone quarries, was charging him too high a rate Trouble Is Due to Operations of freight. He endeavored to reach an agreement with the road, and failing to of John R. Walsh obtain what he considered satisfactory terms constructed a railroad of his own In addition to these two enterprises which he practically owns, Mr. Walsh And the Connection of the is a heavy stockholder in the Akron Business With Politics. Gas company, Akron, O., Illinois Southern Railroad company and Rand, McNally company, Southern Indiana Express company and a half score of Chicago, Dec. 18.-Action has been gas, electric lighting and coal mining taken by the comptroller of the curcompanies. To the stone quarries and rency, William B. Ridgley, that will the Southern Indiana railway Mr. Walsh made heavy loans of the funds compel the three large financial inof the bank and it was these to which stitutions, the Chicago National bank, objection was made by Comptroller the Home Savings bank and the EquitRidgley. able Trust company, dominated by Repeated assurances by the officers John R. Walsh, of this city, to wind of the bank that these loans would be called in, or at least largely curtailed up their affairs. The other national were not fulfilled and finally Mr. banks of Chicago have come to the Ridgley determined on a personal inrescue, and it is declared on the auvestigation. The action of last night thority of the clearing house associafollowed his determination. It is declared by local financiers that tion, the comptroller, and also by the Mr. Walsh has invested all the way officers of the Chicago National bank. from $5,000,000 to $15,000,000 in the that not a single depositor will lose a quarries and the railroad. His great cent. The difficulties of the three desire was to gain for the railroad an wrecks. which are practically branchentrance into Chicago but in this he was not successful. During the last es of the same institution, are attribthree years he has endeavored to sell uted by the comptroller of the curthe road to the Pennsylvania company rency to the large loans made by the but the terms could not be agreed upon Chicago National bank to the railroad, and the sale never could be put through. coal mining and other private enterprises controlled by Mr. Walsh. A Tremendous Surprise. Some time ago the comptroller To the public at large, which was called the attention of the officers of not acquainted with the magnitude of Mr. Walsh's enterprises, the news of the bank to the fact that they were the difficulties surrounding his banks making loans to these enterprises of came as a tremendous surprise. Not Mr. Walsh which in his opinion were a word of the difficulties had reached too large for the safety of the instithe public Saturday night and the first information was conveyed by extra tution. Repeated promises were editions of the morning papers. made that the condition should be Two hours before the time for the rectified, but no action satisfactory to opening of the bank large crowds of the comptroller was taken. Three people who had money in the Chicago days ago he came to Chicago for the National and the Home Savings bank were gathered in front of the banks purpose of making an investigation waiting for the doors to open so that into the affairs of the three banks and they might withdraw their funds. found them in such a condition that Inside the banks ample provision he judged immediate action to be had been made for the impending run, money was laid out in large piles, necessary. Some trifling delay had and additional clerks were stationed at ensued because of the inability of Mr. the paying windows and arrangements Ridgley to meet the officers of the were made in other parts of the bank banks and officials of the state auto pay out the money as fast as it was called for. G. C. Johnson, a messenditor's office. The fact that the Home ger for another bank, who had $10,000 Savings bank and the Equitable Trust in the Home Savings bank. was the company are under state supervision first at the door and he held the head made the presence of the latter offiof the line when the doors were opened cials necessary and the rush began at 10 'clock. It was announced by Vice President Clearing House Call. Blount of the Chicago National bank, The officials of the different Chicago that all demands would be paid as fast banks were told of the situation and a as they were made, by the Chicago hurried call was sent out for a meeting National bank and the Home Savings of representatives of the Chicago clearbank. The latter has the right under association as well the state law to demand 60 days' cers ing house of the city banks. as the offiThe meeting was notice of withdrawal from all deposicalled to order in the office of President tors, but it was decided not to invoke First National this rule and to pay every account as Forgan o'clock of the bank at 3 Sunday afternoon and was in soon as called for continuous session until 5 o'clock this Officers and Directors. morning. A careful canvass of the situaThe officers of the Chicago National tion revealed that the Chicago National bank are: bank had deposits to the amount of President. John R. Walsh: vice $16,000,000. the Home Savings bank had president, Fred M. Blount; cashier, T. savings deposits to the extent of $4,000,M. Jackson 000 divided among about 8,000 depositors. The directors are: F. G. McNally, The liabilities of the two banks, and of John R. Walsh, F. M. Blount, John M. the Equitable Trust company were Smythe, W. Best, C. K. G. Billings, roughly estimated at $26,000,000. The Maurice Rosenfeld. assets of the three institutions made up The officers of the Home Savings about $20,000,000 of the amount and the bank are: directors and officials of the Chicago W. J. Onahan, president; Charles E. came to the Schick, cashier. to about securities National bank amounting front $3,000,000 with The directors are: C. K. G. Billings, more. This left a deficit of about $3,000.Maurice Rosenfeld. John M. Smythe, 000 to be faced and the Chicago W.J Onahan, William Best, F. G. Mcat the represented meeting declared banks at Nally, John R. Walsh. once that they would meet the situation The officers and directors of the and care for the deficit. Equitable Trust company are pracIf it proved necessary to advance any tically the same as those of the two more than $3,000,000 to meet all demands, banks. the banks pledged themselves to make Mr. Walsh kept to his home this up the amount, whatever it might be. morning and declined to see anybody The great difficulty confronting the He has not been well for a number of bankers in the meeting was to arrange a days. and neither yesterday or today legal settlement of the case in the pitiwould he leave his room Callers at fully short time at their disposal at the his residence were referred to the bank hour of commencing business this mornfor all information, and to the request was finally for a statement which was sent to him, ing. addition It to winding arranged that in up the affairs of the Mr. Walsh sent back word: "I have three institutions ,the allied bankers nothing to say. Any statement that is should take all of Mr. Walsh's private to be made will come from the clearenterprises including his coal mines and ing house association.' railroads and stone quarries. At the close of the meeting a stateWALSH PROTESTED. ment was issued by the Chicago clearing


Article from The Laramie Republican, December 18, 1905

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Chicago, Ill., Dec. 18.-The Chicago National bank, the Home Savings bank and the Equitable Trust company, institutions controlled largely by John R. Walsh, did not open for business today. The Chicago clearing house, after a twelve hours' session, early this morning made the announcement that these institutions were bankrupt, but that the Chicago associated banks had guaranteed every liability and would pay every claim. Hundreds of people gathered about the building sheltering the defunct institutions. Walsh has been rated as one of the wealthiest men of Chicago. Private speculations and operations in railroads, coal lands, quarries and other side lines caused his financial collapse. The Chicago National bank will be placed in the hands of a receiver. The savings and trustee companies will go into the state's hands. The former bank had about $15,000,000 on deposit when the ist statement was made and the Home Savings nearly $1,000,000. Walsh resigned as president of the Chicago National today. The total liabillties of the three institutions are $26,000,000. Wash and his associates have turned over $3,000,000, and local bankers will make up the deficit between the assets and liabilities, if any. J. C. Cooper, speaking for Walsh, said the depositors will be paid in full, and that the loss, if any, will fall on the stockholders. Depositors formed long lines and were paid in checks on other banks. Comptroller Ridgely, who has been here three days, said the trouble was caused by Walsh making large loans on industrial and railway enterprises. Walsh once owned the Evening Times and Evening Post. He sold both and acquired the Chicago Chronicle, which he still controls. The promotion of the Southern Indiana railroad is blamed largely for the collapse. The Chicago National bank has been a factor in local politics for many years. At noon the line of depositors extended a block away from the banks.


Article from The Minneapolis Journal, December 18, 1905

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

John R. Walsh, head of t tions which have been decl vent, was not at themeeting. ing were the members at the meeting: J. B. Forgan, cha J. Mitchell, J. H. Eckels, Smith and Ernest A. Hamill Payments Pledged. In addition to the formal of the failure and the ann that the banks involved woul their doors this morning the announcement was made, sig clearinghouse committee of t Associated banks: To the public: Deposit Chicago National bank, the ings bank and the Equit company are respectfully ad their deposits will be paid in " demand. Statement by Ridge The following statement out today by Controller of th William M. Ridgely: "The action of the Chicag house banks in coming to the Chicago National bank, the ings bank and the Equitable pany, has relieved a most c: ation, which, if it had not promptly in hand, might h very serious consequences, I Chicago, but elsewhere. Th the clearinghouse banks mal lutely certain that all the o the three institutions will re money immediately and shou lieve any apprehension on the public in regard to financ in Chicago. Cause of the Break "The critical situation these three concerns / placed has been due to loans made to the rail mining and other enterpri and controlled by John R. V again emphasized the dan managing officers of banks ested in outside institution e large amounts of money. The controller's office h time been criticising the o tional bank and calling upon and directors to reduce the these loans and the investm bonds of Mr. Walsh's corp Promises Not Kep "In spite of repeated pr this should be done these been continued in the bank 8 to prevent further encroachr necessary for the controller t cal action. The controller's office h time been endeavoring to I amination of the Chicago Na simultaneously with the exa the state institutions by the examiner, but was not able t e about until a few days ago. IS of these examinations reve d serious condition that it wa to take immediate action. ] n er telephoned from Washing k ing Bank Examiner Boswor : the matter at once to the the clearinghouse committee Chicago on the first train to d to personally take whatever al necessary. r The Long Confere p "On the arrival of the ( Chicago a conference was e held with the state authori of clearinghouse committee, W it ned from 10 o'clock Sund until 5 o'clock Monday n addition to the clearing ho S. tee, representatives of all Id ing-house banks were calle or ference at about 7 o'clock controller feels that great ( not only to the clearing tee, but to all the other cl banks, for the prompt, vig and the broad-minded spir to meeting this emergency. The Failed Bank The Chicago National b: th ganized in November, 188 authorized capital of $3 creased to $500,000 in 1887 W. 000 in 1901. Its resources, according t th latest reports made to th we of the currency, are $21 e, which nearly $11,000,000 a discounts, with $4,000,000 c The liabilities include nea 000 in individual deposits to 000 due to other banks. the The Home Savings bank the ized originally in 1867, wit zation of $100,000. A late the resources shows an a $4,232,271, of which $3,78 ported as being held in mu road and other bonds. The 1 posits aggregate $3,982,65 The Equitable Trust co i chartered by the state of 0 29, 1887, to act as execu trator, trustee, guardian, B receiver, and to receive trusts of every character. O stock is $500,000. Its r II $4,612,381. The liabilit $2,707,563; of deposits in 323; certificates of depos thru various trusts. i Bank in Politic n The Chicago National ba an active factor in' local several years, and the eng


Article from New-York Tribune, December 19, 1905

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

THREE BANKS SUSPEND J. R. WALSH IN CRASH. Chicago Financiers Guarantee Payment of $26,000,000. [By Telegraph to The Tribune.] Chicago, Dec. 18.-Following the announcement made jointly by the clearing house committee of the Chicago Associated Banks and W. B. Ridgely, the Controller of the Currency in the morning papers to-day- that the three banks here controlled by John R. Walsh-the Chicago National Bank, the Home Savings Bank and the Equitable Trust Company-were financially embarrassed, developments were quick and numerous. The most important fact in the announcement of the bankers, made after a mnineteen-hour meeting, was that the Associated Banks would guarantee that every depositor would be paid in full. This coming upon the heels of the failure of Mr. Walsh's banks was reassuring, not only to the banking fraternity of Chicago, but to the public generally. At no time to-day was there any sign of a panic. Promptly at 10 o'clock this morning long lines of depositors formed at the Chicago National Bank-the home of three Walsh institutionsand with a strong police detail on hand to preserve order the bank's employes began passing out money to depositors and kept it up until the closing hour this afternoon. In this time nearly $6,000,000 of the $26,000,000 deposited in the three institutions had been paid out, and the unpaid depositors outdoors were told to be on hand to-morrow morning, when payments would be resumed. Ample funds had been provided by the other banks of the city, in addition to the available funds of the Walsh banks. Shortly before noon John R. Walsh, president; Fred M. Blount, vice-president, and all the directors of the Chicago National Bank, except C. K. G. Billings, who is in New-York, resigned. They were succeeded by a new orgarization of all the members of the Clearing House Committee of the Chicago Associated Banks, viz.: James B. Forgan, John J. Mitchell, Orson Smith, James H. Eckels. Byron L. Smith, C. K. G. Billings and Charles H. Bosworth. The last named, the national bank examiner who examined the Walsh banks, was elected president of the new organization, whose mission it will be to pay depositors and liquidate the bank's indebtedness. This syndicate has taken over all the assets and liabilities of the Walsh institutions and will try to realize all that is possible from the securities turned over by Mr. Walsh and his associates. These are all valuable, but the col-


Article from The Morning Astorian, December 19, 1905

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

James B. Forgan, president of the First National bank, as head of the clearing house committee of the Chicago Associated banks, gave forth the statement. The assets of these institutions, it was asserted, were involved in coal and railway properties of John R. Walsh, the president of the Chicago National bank. John R. Walsh, head of the institutions which have been declared insolvent, was not at the meeting. The following were the members of the committee at the meeting. James B. Forgan, chairman; John J. Mitchell, James H. Eckles, Orson B. Smith, Ernest A. Hamill. The statement was issued at the offices of the First National bank. It is as follows: "The Chicago National bank, the Home Savings bank, and Equitable Trust Company, which have been controlled and managed by John R. Walsh and his associates have concluded to wind up their affairs and quit business in this city. After a thorough and careful examination of their affairs by the Chicago clearing house banks, it is stated that all of the depositors of these institutions will be paid in full upon demand, the Chicago Clearing House banks having pledged themselves to this result, thus putting all the resources of the Chicago banks behinb the depositers of these three institutions. The difficulty with the institutions has been that investments have been made in assets connected with the railway and coal enterprises of John R. Walsh. "These assets were not immediately available to meet deposits and have been taken over on terms which will enable the three institutions to pay their dem positors in full. Mr. Ridgly, comptroller of the currency, and Charles Eubank, of the auditor's department at Springfield, were seem and expressed themselves as greatly pleased with the action of the Chicago banks, and stated that it rekected great credit upon the associated banks of Chicago which have again indicated their ability to meet and emergency in a manner entirely satisfactory to the public." The meeting of the Chicago clearing house association began at noon Sunday. Notices were sent to the members of the board by Mr. Forgan after it 00 had been learned of the condition of the banks and the trust company. t Clerks were notified and fifty or more with ten stenographers hurried to the First-National Bank. Behind closed doors the Clearing House Association be gan its work of finding a way that might enable them to ride the financial sea in safety. That a panic would be likely to follow was the first thought of the committee. Resolutions were adopted and heads of other banks. pledged themselves to give assistance. The amount involved in the failure would not be stated by 8 the committee members. it All informatin concerning the meetW ing of the committee was kept secret W until three o'clock this morning and half


Article from The Commonwealth, December 22, 1905

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

The Chicago National, the Home Savings and the Equitable Trust Co., three banks controlled by Jno. R. Walsh, suspended operations on the 18th. Liabilities $26,000,000, assets $29,000,000. Loans to Walsh's other interests brought about the failure.


Article from St. Tammany Farmer, December 23, 1905

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

The Chicago National Bank, the Home Savings Bank and the Equitable Trust Company, of Chicago, three institutions in which John R. Walsh is interested suspended business. Politics and injudicious loans was the cause of the crash


Article from The Miller Sun, December 27, 1905

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

HREE BANKS QUIT. ICAGO INSTITUTIONS OF JOHN R. WALSH GO OUT. icago National, Equitable Trust Company and Home Savings Bank Close Business-Two Banks Alone Carry $22,500,000 of Deposits. Liquidation of the Chicago National nk, the Home Savings Bank, and , Equitable Trust Company, all of icago, was announced at 3:30 lock Monday morning by representves of the Chicago Clearing House sociation, after a session lasting thteen hours. James B. Forgan, esident of the First National Bank, head of the clearing house commit: of the Chicago Associated banks, ve forth the statement. The assets these institutions. it was asserted, re involved in coal* and railway perties of John R. Walsh, Presiit of the Chicago National Bank. el statement was issued in the office the First National Bank. It is as lows: "The citizens of Chicago will unibtedly be surprised to learn that : Chicago National Bank, the Home vings Bank, and the Equitable Company, which have been conlled, managed, and officered by in R. Walsh and his associates e concluded to wind up their afrs and quit business in the city of icago, but they will be gratified to rn that after a thorough and careexamination of their affairs by the icago Clearing House banks that of the depositors of these instituas will be pand in full upon dend, the Chicago clearing house ks having pledged themselves to s result, thus putting all the rerees of the Chicago banks behind depositors of these three instituis. The difficulty with the instituhs has been that their investments e been made in assets connected h the railway and coal enterprises John R. Walsh. These assets were immediately available to meet deits in full." The meeting of the Chicago Clearing use Association began at noon Sun. Notices were sent members of the rd by Mr. Forgan after the condition the banks and the trust company had n learned. Clerks were notified and y or more with their stenographers ried to the First National bank. Bed closed doors the Clearing House sociation began its work of finding a y that might enable them to ride the incial sea in safety. That a panic would be likely to fol- was the first thought of the comtee. Resolutions were adopted and ds of other banks pledged themselves give assistance. The amount involvin the failure would not be discussed the committee members. in addition to the formal statement the failure, the following announcent was made, signed by the clearing ise committee of the Chicago assocbanks: pa To the Public: Depositors of the Chio National bank, the Home Savings k. and the Equitable Trust Company


Article from The Lexington Dispatch, January 3, 1906

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Three of the largest financial institutions in the West-the Chicago National bank. the Home Savings bank and the Equitable Truet company of Chicago-all under the control of J. R Walsh - suspended operations on Monday and went into liquadation. Their liabilities are $26,000,000, their nominal assets $16 000,000.


Article from Twice-A-Week Plain Dealer, January 31, 1908

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

which he was president. The penalty is not less than five nor more than ten years' imprisonment. No substitute fine is allowed. The fight for the conviction of Walsh began with the suspension of the Chicago National bank, the Home Savings bank and the Equitable Trust comporr three


Article from Morris Tribune, February 1, 1908

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

which he was president. The penalty is not less than five nor more than ten years' imprisonment. No substitute fine is allowed. The fight for the conviction of Walsh began with the suspension of the Chicago Nation al bank, the Home Savings bank and the Equitable Trust comnenr three


Article from The Washburn Leader, February 7, 1908

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

which he was president. The penalty is not less than five nor more than ten years' imprisonment. No substitute fine is allowed. The fight for the convietion of Walsh began with the suspension of the Chicago National bank. the Home Savings bank and the Equitable Trust company three


Article from The Washington Herald, November 7, 1909

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

names. When it comes to the matter of the law's dealing with them there begins to be a sharp divergence. Charles W. Morse already has tasted of the bitterness of imprisonment. John R. Walsh has not spent an hour in jail, although the crime of which he was convicted and is now under sentence of five years' imprisonment in the Federal penitentiary in Leavenworth, Kans., was committed four years ago, Morse, through the devotion of his wife, regained his liberty, only to be thrust back behind the bars. It was a long and hard task to procure the bond in the first place, It served only as a temporary expedient. Walsh goes to his office in Chicago every day when his seventy-two years will allow him to go, and that is most 01 the time. In spite of his three-score years and twelve. he still has a lot of the energy and fight that made him in former days one of the most conspicuous capitalists and financiers in the West. He has been privileged to be with his devoted family, whose loyalty, in a quieter way, is as beautiful as that of Mrs. Morse toward the Wall street banker He is as welcome as in the old days to the clubs. Those in whose debt he is to the extent of millions are about the last men in Chicago to say for publication anything against the man who weeked the Chicago National Bank and its allied institutions. Similarity of Crimes. Morse and Walsh both were charged with transgressing the banking laws. They used the money of others in a way that the statutes did not sanction, if the charges against them be true. There may have been differences of detail in the alleged wrongful things they did. but the principle involved was the same Compared with Walsh, the Wall street man is still in the prime of life. He might spend a term in prison and come out strong and ready to begin life over again. Recent reports that he added $7,000,000 to his fortune the short time he was out on bond, whether true or not, indicate that the blows that have fallen on him have not put him out of the running as a winner of wealth. For him there is hope after whatever penalty he may pay For Walsh a prison cell probably would mean, sooner or later, a death chamber Mr Walsh is used to hard work, to reckoning with vast detail. Prison life will be no laughing matter for such a man. He has for years been a lord of business over men, brooking no interference with his will He can't be that in Leavenworth. His age renders it unlikely that he will be able to do any physical work His friends feel that once he is restrained behind iron bars the warrant of his death will have been virtually signed. That is the reason they are making with him SO vigorous a fight to ward off the day of reckoning. In the case of this man the mills of the courts are grinding slowly In one month more it will be four years since the three banks, of which Walsh was the executive head, quit doing business and the associated banks of Chicago began to pay the depositors what Walsh owed them The man whose financiering wrecked the banks is still under a big obligation to the Institutions which came to the rescue of the hundreds of depositors. His debt to them is something like $7,000,000 It is the supreme effort of Mr. Walsh just now to raise money to satisfy these creditors, 80 that he will not have to sacrifice many millions of dollars of securities and property History of Walsh's Crime, It was on the morning of December 18. 1905, that the Chicago National Bank, the Home Savings Bank, and the Equitable Trust Company ceased to do business and closed their doors. That was on a Monday morning. Far into the night of Sunday-In fact, till almost the coming of dawn-representatives of the other banks in the Chicago clearing-house had been in conference trying to devise a way to save the banks from wreck and the city from a financial panic. Walsh and his advisers were in that conference. The man who had presided as the financial genius over the trio of banking institutions protested long and loudly that if he were given one more opportunity he would ward off collapse. Over the business of the banks went experts. They scrutinized this account and that. They observed with alarm the long list of menacing obligations, gasped with surprise when informed of the manner in which the funds of the bank-the money of the depositors-were being used to promote private enterprises. They reckoned up the securities for liabilities, figured closely on the conversion possibilities of collateral at hand. They were disposed to be eminently fair, but when they were through canvassing the situation its general aspect was SO forbidding that closing the doors of the institutions was decided on. How Panic Whs Averted. That was the beginning of the end The next morning, which was Monday, there were notices on the Walsh banks which told their tale briefly. The newspapers, which had been purposely let into the secret to help save Chicago from a panic, contained long stories of the fall of the Walsh banks. Every story was quick to say that the associated banks had agreed in conference to guarantee the payment of all deposits, dollar for dollar. All the depositors had to do was to find out what his balance was and write out a check for the amount to another bank chosen for the doing of his future business. He would be given credit for the amount Those who preferred might take their books to the failed banks after they reopened and get their money there. In saving the depositors from losing a cent in the Walsh banks the institutions coming to the rescue were saving themselves the burden of a "scare," which might have far-reaching consequences and precipitate other crashes. On the 5th of October, 1909. nearly four years after that memorable Monday morning, the Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the sentence of five years running against Mr. Walsh, who had been duly convicted in the lower Federal court for violating the banking laws. Owes Banks $7,000,000. At the time the sentence was affirmed, as already stated. Mr. Walsh owed the banks which stood between his institutions and a local financial panic over $7,000,000. secured by the stock and bond issues of certain corporations in which Walsh was interested. The interest havdefaulted


Article from New-York Tribune, May 25, 1911

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

MORSE AND WALSH STAY Continued from first page. denied, with leave to renew the same after January 1, 1913. In reaching these conclusions I follow the recommendation of the Attorney General. In denying the Walsh application the President said, in part: John R. Walsh was convicted of misapplication of the funds of the Chicago National Bank while its president. His pardon is asked, first, because his violations of laws were technical and did not involve moral turpitude and secured him no financial benefit; second. because all the depositors of his banks were paid through the sacrifice of his private fortune; third, because he was, in doing what he did, attempting to upbuild industries of substantial benefit to the country; fourth, because he is an old man. in ill health, not likely to live long, and one who has borne a good reputation and lived a life of simplicity and not of self-indulgence. The facts are that Walsh owned a large interest in three banks-the Chicago National Bank, the Equitable Trust Company and the Home Savings Bank-the latter two Illinois state corporations. He absolutely controlled them. although there was a substantial minority interest in all of them held by others. He used them to furnish the money for the development of several railroads, limestone quarries, coal mines and other enterprises. Using his control of these banks, he took their funds and invested them in enterprises of the character mentioned, either by direct purchase of the bonds, which he had caused to be issued, or by lending from the funds of the bank money on "dummy" notes secured by such bonds as collateral. He risked nearly the whole funds of the three banks in the security of these enterprises, and because of these investments the banks failed. The allied banks of Chicago, in order to prevent a panic, took over the Walsh banks' holdings and Walsh's properties and paid the depositors in full, but in the liquidation the allied banks will


Article from Daily Kennebec Journal, May 25, 1911

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

NO PARDONS. (Continued from Page One.) the recommendations of Mr. Wickersham. President Taft in the Walsh case, said in part: "John R. Walsh was convicted of misapplication of the funds of the Chicago National Bank. while its president. "The facts are that Walsh owned a large interest in three banks-The Chicago National Bark, the Equitable Trust.Co., and The Home Savings Bank, the latter two Illinois state corporations. He used them to furnish tahe money for the development of several railroads, limestone quarries, coal mines and other enterprises. "Using his control of these banks, he took their funds and invested them in enterprises of the character mentioned. either by direct purchase of the Lounds, which he had caused to be issued, or by lending from the funds of the bank money on 'Dummy' notes, secured from such bonds as collecteral. Because of these investmen the banks falled. The alhed ban of Chicago in order to prevent a panie took over the Walsh bankss' holdings and Walsh's properties and paid the depositors in full; but an the liquidation the Allied Banks will sustain a substantial loss. "The application for pardon must be denied. In the first place, the record shows moral turpitude of that inidious and dangerous kind, to punish which the National Banking laws were especially enacted. A bank officer who uses such funds to promote enterprises n in which he has a private interest and without the knowledge and consent of the shareholders for whom he is a trustee, involves the whole capital of n the bank in unauthorized speculation 1from which he is to derive profit if sucis cessful, is guilty of a, fraudulent breach of trust, is guilty of moral ture a pitude and must be punished. No reference to usual business methods, no e suggestion of great business entery prises, no excuse of building up use-


Article from The Marion Daily Mirror, October 10, 1911

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

WILL PAROLE Continued from Page One. turpitude and secured him no financial benefit: that all the depositors of his banks were naid through the sacrifice of This private fortune; tha! he was attempting is bulld up indus of benefit to the country that he is an old not likely to liv long and one who has bornΓ© a good reputation and lived a life of sim plicity and not of elf-indulgence. Will Lead Quiet Life. Walsh was convieted of misapplica tion of the funds of the Chicago National bank, of which he was president. He was sentenced to imprisonment for five years and began serving his sentence January 19, 1910. He owned large interest in three banks: the Chicago National: the Equitable Trust company and the Home Savings bank, and used them to furnish money for the development of several railroads, limestone quarries, coal mines, and other enterprises. The banks failed because of the use of their money in the Walsh enterprises and the other banks of Chicago, in order to avoid a panic, took over their holdings and Walsh's properties and paid the depositors in full, It is understood that Walsh's relatives have arranged to take care of him and to take him to some quiet place in Illinois where he will spend the rest of his days, reporting from time to time through the United States district attorney in the district where he intends to reside.


Article from The Detroit Times, October 11, 1911

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

PRISON DOORS WILL OPEN SOON FOR JOHN R. WALSH Atty.-Gen. Wickersham Approves Board's Recommendation For Parole. WASHINGTON, Oct. 10. - Although official announcement was withheld, it became known today that Attorney-General Wickersham has approved the recommendation of the board of parole that John R. Walsh, the Chicago bank wrecker, be paroled from the Leavenworth penitentiary. In refusing to make public announcement of his decision the attorney-general is merely following the unbroken precedent of the department to maintain secrecy about such matters. This rule was originally established for the protection of prisoners whose efforts to reform would be hampered by publication of their crimes and imprisonment. Walsh made his formal application when the board of parole of the department of justice made its annual visit to Leavenworth last week. The hoard acted favorably on the application and its recommendation was presented to Attorney-General Wickersham yesterday by Superintendent Ladow. The actual date of Walsh's release, life all other details, is withheld by the department of justice and the date on which the aged banker will obtain his liberty will only be known when he is released at Leavenworth. Walsh's parole, with the usual restrictions, requiring him to make regular report to the prison officials. follows an unsuccessful attempt to obtain a pardon from President Taft. On May 24 last, the president refused, saying: "It would defeat the object of the law and present a demoralizing difference between the punishment meted out of the ordinary criminal whose ojrcumstances have naturally led him into crime and one whose position in society should have made for him the strongest restraint against violation of the law." Walsh's plea to the parole board was the same as to the presidentthat his violations of the laws were technical and did not involve moral turpitude and secured him no financial benefit; that all the depositors were paid through the sacrifice of his private fortune, that he was attempting to build up industries of benefit to the country: that he is an old man; net likely to live long. and one who has borne a good reputation and lived a life of simplicity and not of selfindulgence. Walsh was convicted of misapplication of the funds of the Chicago National bank of which he was president. He was sentenced to imprisonment for five years, and began serving his sentence January 19, 1910. He owned a large Interest in three banks -the Chicago National. the Equitable Trust Co. and the Home Savings bank, and used them to furnish money for the development of several railroads, limestone quarries, coal mines and other enterprises. The banks failed because of the use of their money in the Walsh enterprises and the other banks of Chicago, in order to avoid a panic, took over their holdings and Walsh's properties and paid. the depositors in full.