Farmers & Merchants Bank (Vandalia, MI)

Episode Information

Episode UID
74093771488
Episode Type
Run → Suspension → Closure
Bank Type
private
Bank ID
7409377 routing
Routing Number
74-0937
Start Date
December 31, 1923
Location
Vandalia, Michigan (41.917, -85.915)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini (chosen from majority vote of a three-model LLM ensemble)
Short Digest
8c7baf866ea290dc

Response Measures

None

Events (3)

1. December 31, 1923 Run
Cause
Rumor Or Misinformation
Cause Details
Rumors following the state banking department's refusal to approve reorganization/charter precipitated heavy withdrawals
Measures
Attempted to raise funds to tide over withdrawals; ultimately did not open and prepared to seek a receiver
Newspaper Excerpt
Rumors ... caused a run on the bank
Source
newspapers
2. December 31, 1923 Suspension
Cause
Rumor Or Misinformation
Cause Details
Closed after sustained withdrawals following rumors about the failed charter/reorganization
Newspaper Excerpt
The Farmers & Merchants Bank of Vandalia did not open for business Monday morning
Source
newspapers
3. January 10, 1924 Receivership
Newspaper Excerpt
Cashier Carl Fritz has petitioned the Circuit Court for the appointment of a receiver for that bank; receiver for the defunct Farmers' and Merchants' Bank of Vandalia, is expecting to declare a dividend ... (Dec. 11, 1924).
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (6)

Article from Cassopolis Vigilant, January 3, 1924

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

VANDALIA BANK CLOSED MONDAY Cashier Carl Fritz Issues Statement to Bank's Depositors The Farmers & Merchants Bank of Vandalia did not open for business Monday morning, and has not opened since, and Cashier Fritz will petition the Circuit Court for the appointment of a receiver for the bank in order that the depositors may realize as largely as possible from the bank's assets. The closing of the bank's doors was a surprise to many. The bank was organized twelve years ago by Mr. Fritz and a man named Gunn, who at that time resided at Saginaw but is now engaged in manufacturing in Canada. The bank enjoyed a good business and Cashier Fritz enjoyed the confidence of the people of Vandalia and vicinity, so that the deposits sometimes reached approximately one hundred and fifty thousand dollars. The past few months Mr. Fritz had been working to organize a stock company to take over the bank and operate it as a State Bank. Seventy-eight persons subscribed for the $25,000 of capital stock, the shares selling at $125.00 each, $100 being capital stock and the other $25.00 of each share going to create a surplus fund, which would have made a strong bank for the community. The following named men were elected directors of the proposed state bank: Wm. Coulter, Chas. F. Born, Elmer Benham, P. C. Hunt, Henry H. Born and Carl Fritz. At a meeting for the purpose of considering taking over the assets of the Farmers & Merchants Bank, the directors of the new organization passed a resolution declining such action. Following this a "run" started on the bank and kept up for several days, with the result that at the close of business Saturday evening Mr. Fritz knew the bank could not long continue to pay out money at the rate it was being demanded without jeopardizing the interests of the remaining depositors, and, after making strenuous efforts to raise money to tide over the run, he decided to not open the bank on Monday and to petition for the appointment of a receiver. The Vigilant knows nothing of the nature of the paper held by the bank or the value of its assets, but in an interview with Mr. Fritz who was in Cassopolis on Tuesday, he said that if the affairs of the bank could be economically administered he had no fear but that depositors would get all their money. He has issued the following statement to depositors: Vandalia, Michigan, December 31, 1923. To the Patrons and Customers of the Farmers & Merchants Bank of Vandalia, Cass County, Michigan: Friends: It is with the profoundest regret that I make this announcement. The above bank was established in 1912. Since that time I have devoted my time and my energy and my best thought to make it a success for the benefit of the people of Vandalia and the surrounding country. It has been a successful institution and was getting along and doing a nice business. However within the last year there was a feeling among the people and its patrons which was approved by the owners of the bank that it would grow to be a bigger and better institution if it were under State supervision. Therefore I, during the summer past made application for a state charter. It was approved by the state banking department. Articles of incorporation were filed and approved. A board of directors was elected to take charge of the bank when a charter would be granted. The banking department sent a representative to look over the assets of the Farmers & Merchants bank and I had every assurance that the State Bank to be organized would take over the assets of the Farmers & Merchants Bank so far as they were approved by the Bank examiner. Unfortunately however at the last meeting of the Board of Directors with the bank examiner a resolution was passed refusing to take over any of the assets or the building and fixtures of the old bank in consequence of which no charter was granted. Rumors began to circulate which resulted in depositors gradually withdrawing the whole or part of their funds from the bank until I found that it would be impossible to keep the bank open longer without greatly jeopardizing the assets, and entailing a loss to the depositors. I therefore felt justified in closing and did close the bank on the morning of December 31, 1923, and applied for a receiver that the assets may be conserved and a proper distribution made thereof. The books of the bank show that the assets exceed the liabilities and it is my sincere hope and wish that the receiver whoever may be appointed will so handle the affairs of the bank that every depositor will receive one hundred cents on a dollar. CARL FRITZ, Cashier.


Article from The Kalamazoo Gazette, January 3, 1924

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

RECEIVER WILL GIVE DATA ON DEFUNCT BANK Information on Vandalia Crash Up to Man to Be Appointed. DOWAGIAC, Jan. 3—Refusal of officials of the defunct Farmers' and Merchants' bank of Vandalia to reveal the number of depositors, amount of deposits or figures on its last balance sheets, is based on a decision to turn all this information over to the receiver, yet to be appointed, according to Carl Fritz, cashier, and one of the owners of the institution. "We will give all this information to the receiver, and that official can make public any figures that he desires," said Mr. Fritz. The Vandalia bank which closed its doors Monday morning, crashed when rumors growing out of the failure of that state bank examiner to approve reorganization as a state bank, caused a run on the bank. REFUSES INFORMATION Hugh McPherson, state banking commissioner, has refused to divulge the information why a charter was refused, except to say that the bank failed to meet requirements of the banking laws. The Vandalia bank was the third to fail in Cass county in the last two years. The other two institutions now in the hands of a receiver are the Farmers' bank at Jones and the First State bank at Marcellus. Mr. Fritz Wednesday consulted with the referee in bankruptcy at Benton Harbor to learn the procedure of securing a receivership. Thursday he expected to confer with Circuit Judge Glenn Warner at Paw Paw regarding the bank failure. EXPECTS TO PAY ALL Though no financial statement has been issued by the bank, Mr. Fritz announced his confidence that all depositors and creditors will receive payment in full. The bank has been operated as a private institution since 1912. William H. Gunn, now of Canada, was Mr. Fritz's partner. The bank was capitalized at $12,000. Reorganization of the bank as a state institution had been completed. Stock amounting to $25,000 with a surplus of $25 a share or $6,250 had been subscribed. William Coulter, Percy C. Hunt, Charles Born, Imer Benham, H. H. Brown and Carl Fritz had been named directors.


Article from The Herald-Press, January 4, 1924

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

RECEIVER WILL GIVE DATA ON DEFUNCT BANK Information On Vandalia Crash Up To Man To Be Appointed DOWAGIAC, Jan. 4.—Refusal of officials of the defunct Farmers' and Merchants' bank of Vandalia to reveal the number of depositors, amount of deposits or figures on its last balance sheets, is based on a decision to turn all this information over to the receiver, yet to be appointed, according to Carl Fritz, cashier and one of the owners of the institution. "We will give all this information to the receiver, and that official can make public any figures that he desires," said Mr. Fritz. The Vandalia bank which closed its doors Monday morning, crashed when rumors growing out of the failure of that state bank examiner to approve reorganization as a state bank, caused a run on the bank. Refuses Information Hugh McPherson, state banking commissioner, has refused to divulge the information why a charter was refused, except to say that the bank failed to meet requirements of the banking laws. The Vandalia bank was the third to fail in Cass county in the last two years. The other two institutions now in the hands of a receiver are the Farmers' bank at Jones and the First State bank at Marcellus. Mr. Fritz Wednesday consulted with the referee in bankruptcy, Willard Banyon, in St. Joseph, to learn the procedure of securing a receivership. Thursday he conferred with Circuit Judge Glenn Warner at Paw Paw regarding the bank failure. Though no financial statement has been issued by the bank, Mr. Fritz announced his confidence that all depositors and creditors will receive payment in full. The bank has been operated as a private institution since 1912. William H. Gunn, now in Canada, was Mr. Fritz's partner. The bank was capitalized at $12,000. Reorganization of the bank as a state institution had been completed. Stock amounting to $25,000 with a surplus of $25 a share or $6,250 had been subscribed. William Coulter, Percy C. Hunt, Charles Born, Elmer Benham, H. H. Brown and Carl Fritz had been named directors.


Article from Cassopolis Vigilant, January 10, 1924

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

CASHIER FRITZ ASKS FOR BANK RECEIVER Four Other Suits Started in the Circuit Court the Past Week Cashier Carl Fritz of the Farmers and Merchants Bank of Vandalia has petitioned the Circuit Court for the appointment of a receiver for that bank. In his petition Mr. Fritz sets forth that on Sept. 18, 1912, Wm. Gunn of Saginaw, Wm. H. Proctor of Ypsilanti and himself entered into a partnership for the establishment of the Farmers and Merchants Bank of Vandalia, each partner paying in three thousand dollars; that the capital stock was later increased to twelve thousand dollars; that in May, 1918, Mr. Proctor died, and Gunn & Fritz bought of his heirs his interest in the bank; that Wm. Gunn was president and Carl Fritz cashier; that recently the question of organizing a state bank was discussed and agitated in Vandalia and vicinity; that application was made to the state banking department and approved; that articles of incorporation were filed and approved; that an inspection of the assets of the partnership bank was made by a representative of the state banking department and a part of the assets approved and some rejected; that every demand of the state banking department was complied with but for some unknown and undisclosed purpose the banking department through its representative kept bringing up one thing after another and when it found every condition imposed could be complied with and after keeping the new stockholders, the board of directors and members of this partnership in suspense for a considerable length of time then the department declined to grant a charter; that the total liabilities of the partnership bank are now a little in excess of fifty-three thousand dollars; that the total assets of the bank are a little in excess of sixty-five thousand dollars; that as a result of the refusal of the state banking department to grant a charter for a state bank, as complainant believes, depositors began withdrawing their funds from the bank until, on the advice of counsel, the bank closed its doors on Dec. 31, 1923; that the business cannot be continued under prevailing circumstances and that if depositors should continue to withdraw funds it would be necessary to sacrifice the bank's securities in order to realize cash, entailing great loss; that it is impossible to continue the business without jeopardizing the interests of the creditors and the partners. Mr. Fritz therefore prays that the Court will appoint a temporary as well as a permanent receiver to take charge and possession of all the property, rights and credits of Gunn & Fritz. Marion Hamilton of Silver Creek has commenced suit to regain title to forty acres of land in that township which is a part of her farm but which was sold for taxes because of an error of description, it being another piece of land in a different part of the township on which the taxes were delinquent. The suit is brought against George F. Brown of Flint, owner of the tax title, and Oramel B. Fuller, auditor general. The Cass County State Bank has commenced suit against Wm. Gemberling and sureties to collect on a note for $214.50 given last March. George B. Jones has commenced suit by attachment against William Reed of Silver Creek township to collect $282.48. Levy was made upon Reed's farm in Silver Creek. Mrs. Lottie Guttmacher of Dowagiac, whose maiden name was Flox, has commenced suit against Samuel Guttmacher for divorce. They were married April 30, 1917, and separated Dec. 26, 1923. They have two children, aged four and two years. She alleges extreme cruelty and asks for alimony for herself and children of two hundred dollars per month pending the hearing of the suit. She also asks for separate maintenance and for the care and custody of the two children. Upon her petition an injunction was issued restraining Mr. Guttmacher from entering upon her premises or otherwise interfering with her pending the trial of their case, and from encumbering or disposing of their property. Articles of association have been filed with County Clerk Stahl for the Dowagiac Finance Corporation, the business of which shall be to buy and sell real estate, mortgages, tax titles and contracts. The organizers are G. W. Howes, Jas. F. Firestone, Arthur H. Frazee and J. N. Bilderback. Claude Clark of Dowagiac has commenced suit against the Wolverine Motor Insurance Co. of Dowagiac to collect five hundred dollars damages which he alleges resulted to his auto from a collision which occurred last November, he having carried insurance in the Wolverine Co. and having been denied a settlement by them.


Article from The Kalamazoo Gazette, December 11, 1924

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANK RECEIVER TO PAY 20 PER CENT DIVIDEND CASSOPOLIS, Dec. 11.—Robert J. Anderson, receiver for the defunct Farmers' and Merchants' Bank of Vandalia, is expecting to declare a dividend of at least 20 per cent in time for the holidays. This will be the second dividend that the bank has paid—the first being for 20 per cent. The checks sent out, Mr. Anderson expects, will come in handy for Christmas presents—or even for the tax collector.


Article from The Dowagiac Daily News, June 25, 1927

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

REAL ESTATE REAL ESTATE Ruskin B. Phillips to Peter H. Kindig. lot 19, Idlewilde. Ida Pierce et al to Israel Glaser, E½ SE% Section 31, Howard. Irene Calnon to James Sams, lot 6. East Lawn. B. Frank Stickler to Vernie V. Dowell, lot 76, Midway park. Rose Arbor to Chas. O. Burch. part lot 98. McOmber's addition. Joseph Parker et al to Elzie H. Hulett, lot 41, Forest Home. Chas. K. Minary Benton Har bor-St. Joe Railway &. Light Co., land in sections and Pokagon. Geo. W. Perrault to John Collinane. land in section 5, Silver John D. Cullinane to Geo. W. Perrault et al. land in section 3., Silver Creck. Fred H. Baker by Exr. to Horace Curtis, lot 36. Maple Island. Chas. Wickwire to Hamilton Irwin, S½ lots 54. and 55. Breese McConnell's addition. Dowaglac. Tittle to Noble Allen. lot 54, Noble Allen to F. Tittle. land in section Jeptha Keyser to Leolin Long. land in section 14, Pokagon. Emma Ocenia Sears et al to Lucy E. Glass et al. lot 58, Birch Shores. Lydia Taylor to Addison E. Sill, lot 10. block 2 north, east. Frank A. Clelland et al to Oscar Romig. land in section 11. Volinia. Roy E. Durocher to Clarence Timm, land in section 10. South Por. ter. Fred J. Riley et al to Russell Goodenough. land in NW% Sec. 24. Volinia. Clyde W. Waltz to Daniel E. Lynch, lot Schell Beach plat. Jason H. Kingsley George Kantz, land in section 15. Ontwa. Addison E. Sill to Enoch Bogert. lot 13, block north, west, Mar. cellus. Beckwith Co. to August Yonke. lot 146. Hopkins addition. Dowagiac Sigmond to Geo. R. Dater. land NEW section Pokagon Farmers and Merchants bank receiver to Fred Tictsort. lot 38. Sue Bogue's addition. Vandalia. Bertha Arndt Clinton Gray land in SW% section 21. Volinia. Sadie M. Shillito to Case On Co., part lots and 2. block south. Frank Shaffer to A. L. Maw. 90 Mortgages recorded $9,334.00. Mortgages discharged